The worst year for car fatalities was 1938. You had a like 1 in 3000 chance. That’s exceedingly rare in my book. Again, I’m not against seat belt laws. I’m just saying they work just as well if you don’t live in constant fear of death.
First, again, I am not arguing against seat belt laws. Repeat: I. am. not. against seat belt laws. I’m assuming this is the misunderstanding and why I keep getting downvoted into oblivion and getting weird replies. If not, then why? I’m not understanding this push back.
What I’m saying is that it’s not psychologically healthy to think your daily commute is a war zone and obsess on worst case scenarios like the comments my original comment was in response to.
Now with the numbers.
In the US, during the 30s, about 1 out of 3,000 people died in car accidents each year. By the 70s, with road safety improvements and such, this was down to 1 out of 5,000. Then in the 90s with seat belt laws, it was about 1 out 6,500. Today, with a half dozen air bags in each car, it’s 1 out of 10,000.
I just have an issue with misuse of statistics. “1 in 3000 people died in car accidents each year” is a useless number that gives you no information you can base a decision on, though granted, it’s at least more info than before. But still, what do we get from it? Assuming it’s correct, is it saying that for every 3000 deaths 1 was in a car crash? If so, seeing as that figure was around 2.2% in 2017, with much better traffic laws, infinitely safer cars, better road design, construction, and materials… You can draw exactly zero conclusions from that stat. Were a lot more people dying in the 30s from other preventable causes? Are people now a dying much less? No idea. There’s so much noise, how do you even factor in seat belts?
If you want to draw conclusions from statistics you need to use the right ones. If we’re comparing traffic safety then at least start here: how do injuries+deaths/km travelled compare from the 30s to now?
I didn’t downvote, but I already mentioned my objection that ‘dead or alive’ aren’t the only two possible outcomes of a car trip. So the calculation should be different.
The person who put her legs up on the dashboard and ended up with said legs way in her pelvis, has lived iirc.
Also, this is a prime example of a ‘black swan’ event: happens rarely, but when it does, you really fucking wish it didn’t.
You’ll drive yourself insane thinking like this. And that’s my concern about modern society. When seat belt laws were passed half a century ago, we never thought about our legs being shoved up into our pelvis. We understood that it was a “carpet bombing” law. If you force a quarter billion people to wear seat belts, it’ll prevent thousands of deaths and injuries. But me personally, whether I wear a seat belt or not, I am just as safe. People have lost sight of that today.
Also btw, your general attitude regarding any kind of black-swan event should be ‘huh, perhaps I should avoid that at a small cost, in case it fucks my entire family for three generations’, and not ‘who the fuck cares’. That’s wisdom.
Again. I was not saying don’t wear seat belts. I was saying prepare for black swan events but remember that they are black swan events and not the norm.
I’m feeling like Not Sure trying to explain that I’m pretty sure plants need water.
The worst year for car fatalities was 1938. You had a like 1 in 3000 chance. That’s exceedingly rare in my book. Again, I’m not against seat belt laws. I’m just saying they work just as well if you don’t live in constant fear of death.
1 in 3000 per km travelled? Per year? Every time you get in the car? Per day? Per crash? What are these numbers.
First, again, I am not arguing against seat belt laws. Repeat: I. am. not. against seat belt laws. I’m assuming this is the misunderstanding and why I keep getting downvoted into oblivion and getting weird replies. If not, then why? I’m not understanding this push back.
What I’m saying is that it’s not psychologically healthy to think your daily commute is a war zone and obsess on worst case scenarios like the comments my original comment was in response to.
Now with the numbers.
In the US, during the 30s, about 1 out of 3,000 people died in car accidents each year. By the 70s, with road safety improvements and such, this was down to 1 out of 5,000. Then in the 90s with seat belt laws, it was about 1 out 6,500. Today, with a half dozen air bags in each car, it’s 1 out of 10,000.
I just have an issue with misuse of statistics. “1 in 3000 people died in car accidents each year” is a useless number that gives you no information you can base a decision on, though granted, it’s at least more info than before. But still, what do we get from it? Assuming it’s correct, is it saying that for every 3000 deaths 1 was in a car crash? If so, seeing as that figure was around 2.2% in 2017, with much better traffic laws, infinitely safer cars, better road design, construction, and materials… You can draw exactly zero conclusions from that stat. Were a lot more people dying in the 30s from other preventable causes? Are people now a dying much less? No idea. There’s so much noise, how do you even factor in seat belts?
If you want to draw conclusions from statistics you need to use the right ones. If we’re comparing traffic safety then at least start here: how do injuries+deaths/km travelled compare from the 30s to now?
I think it’s rather that 1/3000th of the total population died in car crashes each year, and your job as a voter was to judge if that’s acceptable.
Christ… That’s grim.
‘Unsafe at Any Speed’
I didn’t downvote, but I already mentioned my objection that ‘dead or alive’ aren’t the only two possible outcomes of a car trip. So the calculation should be different.
The person who put her legs up on the dashboard and ended up with said legs way in her pelvis, has lived iirc.
Also, this is a prime example of a ‘black swan’ event: happens rarely, but when it does, you really fucking wish it didn’t.
You’ll drive yourself insane thinking like this. And that’s my concern about modern society. When seat belt laws were passed half a century ago, we never thought about our legs being shoved up into our pelvis. We understood that it was a “carpet bombing” law. If you force a quarter billion people to wear seat belts, it’ll prevent thousands of deaths and injuries. But me personally, whether I wear a seat belt or not, I am just as safe. People have lost sight of that today.
Also btw, your general attitude regarding any kind of black-swan event should be ‘huh, perhaps I should avoid that at a small cost, in case it fucks my entire family for three generations’, and not ‘who the fuck cares’. That’s wisdom.
Again. I was not saying don’t wear seat belts. I was saying prepare for black swan events but remember that they are black swan events and not the norm.
I’m feeling like Not Sure trying to explain that I’m pretty sure plants need water.