A final reason to question Israel strategic value is that it sometimes does not act like a loyal ally. Like most states Israel looks first to its own interests. It has been willing to do things contrary to American interests when it believed this would help its own national goals.
In the notorious Lavon affair in 1954 Israeli agents tried to bomb several US government offices in Egypt. It was a bungled attempt to sow discord between Washington and Cairo.
Israel sold military supplies to Iran while US diplomats were held hostage there in 1979 and 1980. It was one of Iran main military suppliers during the Iran-Iraq War. This was even though the United States was worried about Iran and tacitly backing Iraq. Israel later purchased $36 million worth of Iranian oil in 1989. It was an attempt to get release of Israeli hostages in Lebanon. All these acts made sense from Israel point of view but they were contrary to American policy and harmful to overall US interests.
Israel has also transferred American technology to third countries. This includes potential US adversaries like China. These actions violated US laws and threatened American interests.
In 1992 the State Department inspector general reported that starting in 1983 there was evidence of a “systematic and growing pattern of unauthorized transfers” by Israel.
At about same time General Accounting Office officials looked into the Dotan affair. This was embezzlement and illegal diversion of millions of dollars of US military aid by former head of Israeli Air Force procurement. GAO made repeated efforts to meet with Israeli officials to discuss the matter. According to GAO, “The Government of Israel declined to discuss the issues or allow investigators to question Israeli personnel.”
Even Douglas Feith was reportedly angry. He was former undersecretary of defense and a consistent supporter of Israel. He was angry when Israel agreed in 2004 to upgrade a killer drone it had sold to China in 1994. Another senior Bush administration official said “Something is going badly wrong in the military relationship.”
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy

