EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]

Vigilance and compassion

  • 1 Post
  • 17 Comments
Joined 6 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 22nd, 2020

help-circle





  • So, what are you even saying to me? What did I say wrong that you think somehow invalidates my line of questioning? What “fascist pseudoscience” did I communicate?

    What are you trying to say here? Do you actually believe that no sterilizations occurred or do you disagree that it constitutes genocide?

    I have a feeling that you’re not actually saying what you think because you recognize that stating your actual beliefs would result in a ban.


  • I think that’s something interesting about liberal racism, where they don’t actually care if they’re accurate. Conservative racism starts from the standpoint of hating people and then works forward towards justifying reasons for their hate.

    Liberal racism instead works backwards from hating having their beliefs called into question, and then they find themselves blindly walking backwards into racism.


  • Beta Israel is the demonym that they use to describe themselves. There are several members of my Synagogue who are Beta Israel, all of whom are very explicit about rejecting the labels “Ethiopian Jew” and “Falasha/Falashim”.

    You are rejecting the preferred self-designation of this community. That really concerns me, and makes me less confident that you’ve put in the research to be able to even discern what is or is not good faith on this subject.

    Do you also deny the Yemenite Children Affair (Parshat Yaldei Teiman)?










  • And this kind of identity-only criticism can be used upside down by reactionary forces, which basically reinforces the idea around men that feminism is only about hating men, and not about how patriarchy negatively affects all our lives. And we also have the reverse of anti-men identity politics movement, with anti-women identity politics by incels and red pills, which itself is a reaction against liberal feminism.

    This is just victim blaming, it’s not even remotely useful commentary. Women do not have to be perfect paragons of social justice who must do all the emotional labour in the world so that men can’t twist their words. There is no sincere misandrist movement anywhere and feminism is in no way to blame for incels. Again, this is just victim blaming.


    The other problem regarding this type of politics, is that it isn’t actionable. Yes, men are terrible, but can you get rid of them? Is it a desirable thing to have a society with women-only? What are you going to do with the existing men? Are they just going to disappear?

    This is where both your comment and your thought process should have started. Valerie Solanas is maybe one of the only thinkers to take this line of reasoning to its conclusion, and her writing is incredibly revealing with regards to why it’s an inherently flawed standpoint.