• 0 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 31st, 2023

help-circle







  • I’d just like to add an argument against the death penalty. The common argument is that we sometimes get it wrong so we can’t have it because you can’t reverse the sentence, and that is a strong enough argument. However, if one day we have a justice system that can be 100.000% certain of guilt (or society at large is persuaded of this, even if it isn’t true…) then I still don’t believe we should have the death penalty, because it’s not possible to be 100% certain that there is no chance of rehabilitation. I’m someone who has had a family member horrifically and senselessly murdered, and I still believe revenge achieves exactly nothing. It just adds bodies to the pile and increases suffering. It won’t bring back your loved ones, or, crucially, reduce your suffering one iota to see the guilty suffer or die.
    The question really is: why the hell would any civilised society, whose citizens believe themselves to have mastered their animalistic nature, want the death penalty?



  • When you use the quote tool (>) you’re supposed to actually quote the person. What you have done here is called a “misquote”. Do you understand the concept? Because if you do you will know that it instantly discredits your argument. In this particular case it goes even further and makes your argument unintelligible. It’s impossible to respond meaningfully because it’s nonsense. Either it’s a strategy or an oversight. Either way, not a good look I’m afraid.

    Anyway, your second paragraph. Are there no possible ways for a person to get arrested that you wouldn’t object to? Do you think laws are automatically ethically correct and perfectly applied in every case?



  • every accusation is a confession

    You’ve been running scared of your position this entire thread

    Yes.

    I’ll address your ridiculous claims though, since you asked. I don’t love terrorists. It’s a moronic proposition anyway based on the subjectivity of the word. I don’t hate Jews, and it’s very weird you brought that up since neither of us have mentioned Jews up until this point. Are you getting confused with another thread maybe? I don’t want to rape anyone, and again, this is the first mention of any type of sexual assault in our discussion so it’s very hard to be sure where you’re getting this from. I don’t want to murder anyone at all, whether they disagree with me or not. The only violent speech in this discussion has come from you.
    So - it’s another bunch of accusations which have come completely unfounded and out of nowhere. My first guess would be that they are projection of your own mental state, but feel free to correct me if you like.