Been thinking a lot about the state of organizing in the US Empire, and increasingly I’ve come to the conclusion that the main 2 options for anyone organizing are either the DSA while joining an explicitly ML caucus (at the moment Red Star) with the “DSA as the incubator for the vanguard, not the vanguard itself” strategy, or PSL. Starting a new org is tremendously difficult, and will likely come from a split from another org, rather than growing from a study circle like Red Clarion proposes.

Joining the DSA and an ML caucus is like a microcosm of being in the PSL, just narrowing your exposure largely to radicalized workers. The DSA is where the radicalized liberals flock to, not the PSL. This has tremendous advantage in terms of exposure, but you deal with the DSA’s paper membership. The 130,000 members the DSA promotes sound incredible on paper, until you realize that there is no commitment requirements to speak of. Nevertheless, an ML faction within the org has the ability to steer the org in a more correct direction and perhaps can form the basis of either a split from the DSA, or a new center to purge the reformists and force them to split. In either case, it isn’t a strategy without historic basis.

The PSL is a weak ML org. It has problems with the structure and adherance of democratic centralism, and has rapidly grown in the last couple of years to its own detriment, as the party seemed ill-equipped to handle this influx. There are problems with how discipline is handled, and the strategy for recruitment is a high bar, as it is a cadre org. Nevertheless, it is far more theoretically correct than the DSA could hope to be without the aforementioned purge of reformists, and at the present moment I have more faith in their ability to improve as an organization thanks to their cadre approach than I do the DSA to become a good org.

An org is its members, no matter how good or bad the structures you create are in theory, you need the highest level cadre to execute good structures well and mitigate the problems of weak structures. The primary weaknesses of the PSL can be overcome from within, I believe, by virtue of being a cadre org, than the DSA can by being a mass org. I might be proven wrong in the coming years, but this is historically why cadre orgs even exist in the first place, and Red Star Caucus has a long way to go to transition the DSA to an ML org.

The main tasks of the Statesian MLs are to build up cadre, and build up organization within the working class. Membership is fragmented. I expect either the DSA to split or the PSL to overtake them, and any ML should be watching the movement carefully. There could even be a new org that gains in membership quickly, like the Trotskyist RCI, only with an ML line. However, this is not that moment. This is the time before a vanguard has formed, and thus it’s our job to gain as much organizing experience as possible and front the most correct lines as possible, with careful attention to settler-colonialism as is often neglected.

CPUSA is thoroughly compromised and reformist. FRSO has been a tiny org for decades and minimizes settlers colonialism. Unlike the DSA, the CPUSA is too small the party incubation strategy to make any coherent sense, it’s weaker than the DSA as a reformist org and weaker than the PSL as a demcent org. It’s the worst of both worlds. Therefore, any communist should look to see the status of their local DSA and PSL, depending on which strategy you believe most advances your own organizing skills and your ability to advance a correct ML line to the radicalized working class.

I wish I had a definitive answer at this time, but there isn’t a vanguard. In the aftermath of the midterm elections, most of the energy is in the DSA, which invites new opportunity for communists to expose the working class to a correct understanding of theory and practice. However, this energy can quickly fizzle out as the DSA is not a cadre org and is reformist, so this moment in particular should fade. Where we go from there depends on the ever-shifting landscape.

Thoughts?

  • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.mlOP
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    12 days ago

    Sure, on this we have to understand that the primacy of the settler-colonial nature of the US, we must form a party focused on the oppressed nations, especially indigenous. PSL is, among communist organizations in the US, the least bad on this one. FRSO rejects settler-colonialism in the US, as USU points out, and the DSA doesn’t have a strong pro-indigenous line. The PSL recognizes the right of nations to self-determination, including secession, and primarily recruits from oppressed nations (though many Euro-settler workers also join).

    Again, I need to stress that I’m not a ride-or-die PSL fan or anything, I just do not see a rising local party turning empire-wide. I’m not trying to dismiss the people trying, I have just seen no success on that front yet. Perhaps I’m just blind to it, but is the answer really that every communist should focus primarily on forming study groups when the primary issue is a lack of organization? Am I mistaken on the primary issue, or am I mistaken on the rectification of it?

    • LeninZedong@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      12 days ago

      It is difficult to say if a local party could rise up to do what a vanguard party should do, since we would essentially be speculating on a hypothetical organization that does not have any significant amount of documentation. I do not disagree with you on the matter of organization, and I do think that it is better to focus on resolving organization issues over study group formation.

      For me, I do not see any organization currently in existence that has principled Marxist takes on all things that would follow a party for the proletariat, but that is just me.

      • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.mlOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        11 days ago

        Yes, I guess I could say my ideal scenario is a perfect party forms and rapidly reaches sizable membership numbers, but I am trying to balance that with pragmatism in the immediate moment.

    • chinawatcherwatcher@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      12 days ago

      I just do not see a rising local party turning empire-wide. I’m not trying to dismiss the people trying, I have just seen no success on that front yet. Perhaps I’m just blind to it, but is the answer really that every communist should focus primarily on forming study groups when the primary issue is a lack of organization? Am I mistaken on the primary issue, or am I mistaken on the rectification of it?

      lot of interesting thoughts and ideas in this thread, hope you don’t mind if i tag along in this conversation.

      although i have limited personal experience to draw from, i personally feel that the primary contradiction in this context is a lack of development (political, historical, philosophical) rather than a lack of organization, although organization is obviously important. if socialism truly is scientific, then its practitioners will need to have as much expertise and ability to wield that expertise as those in the physical sciences. i also don’t think that being well-read necessarily translates to high development: reading is not necessarily learning, and i think there are serious philosophical deficiencies in most peoples’ level of development.

      another thing that indicates to me that this is the primary contradiction within the western left is the relative paucity of groundbreaking theory being published by the “big four,” let alone their hesitancy to call out opposing organizations for having an incorrect line for fear of being seen as “breaking left unity.” if i actually want to read amazing new theory, it never actually comes from anyone associated with these organizations. if there were a correct line i would expect that correct line to fiercely defend itself with incontrovertible theoretical arguments, and to harshly (or at least openly) criticize those who are incorrect in the same way that lenin often did. the fact that USU is better at this despite its low level of organization and relative lack of editorial control speaks volumes to me.

      so, i tend to think that building local study groups is a more likely path to eventual success than trying to split existing organizations, although this is far from the only reason why. i think it makes much more sense for a legitimate grassroots organization to be built up from the bottom rather than down from the top. and, i also think the formation of that kind of party is a process that would likely take decades, and would obviously be less visibly successful in its embryonic stage. as far as USU specifically, i agree with this line but disagree with their implementation: their attempts at forming the AEWL seem adventurist and idealist, and their publications are not nearly professional enough.

      obviously organization and organizing experience is important (and, incidentally, organizing a study group does give you some of that experience!). but, how many orgs have published truly scientific, professional theory regarding…how to organize in the first place? how many have really gotten down to brass tacks on a comparison of organizational structures of all past communist parties, and then made a reasonable case for the application of that information to the present day? in my experience this kind of stuff is a dogmatic copy/paste at best, and totally based on vibes at worst. why has there been little to no development on the theory and practice of demcent, or perhaps most importantly of all on opportunism? i’d be happy to be proven wrong, but this is why i think theoretical development is too low and that low level of development is the primary contradiction in the west.

      • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.mlOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        11 days ago

        Lot of great points, and of course I don’t mind your participation! I expected this thread to be a bit “spicy” so to speak, and am genuinely happy with everyone bringing their own points forward so I can correct my own views. One thing I want to respond to in particular is the study group and the publication of new theory.

        I focus a decent chunk of my time refining my basic Marxist-Leninist reading list, and we actually began a study circle over on Hexbear for it a couple of days ago, led by comrade Edie. Pedagogy and study has been a particular area of interest, and one I have always felt was sorely lacking in online spaces in ways that keeps the theory relevant to the modern day, rather than looking like a bibliography of Marx/Engels/Lenin/Stalin/Mao. Their works are critically important, no doubt, but there is very little good new theory being written.

        I’ve actually considered dabbling in that realm myself, but basically want to hold off on that until I consider myself having graduated from “baby ML” to “proper ML,” which I anticipate to be in a few years time. You’re right, reading is not the same as developing, and I want to sharpen my development far more so that I can help contribute to new theory development, largely in the form of Red Sails style essays.

        Thanks for your input!

        • chinawatcherwatcher@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          8 days ago

          hahaha i am also on the road from baby to proper in a sense, focusing more on developing life skills and exploring theoretical ideas myself before i jump back into studying theory. but, i also want to suggest and encourage you to write now even if you don’t consider yourself fully developed yet. writing is a skill like any other, a creative skill that encourages you to look at readings in a more critical lens that you might otherwise. i find myself writing a lot about theory even though, to be honest, i haven’t read any for several years. to that end, if you ever write something and want feedback i’m always willing to give some, even if i don’t consider myself very developed.

          i’ve also taken a relatively serious interest in pedagogy, optimizing the process of learning, and ToK (in a more practical than theoretical sense) so that when i begin studying things again it is more serious and has more longevity, i.e. that i will be studying them rather than simply reading them. after all, many people will need to learn theory and many people will need to teach theory if any success is to be made, and i have a particular passion for teaching. and, while the krupskaya piece on how to study is fine, i find it woefully incomplete and incorrect ~100 years later.

          anyways, interesting thread! i think it’s good to muse about general strategy like this every once in a while.

          • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmygrad.mlOP
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            7 days ago

            No problem! And yes, I totally understand the interest in both how to teach and how to study! It’s a category I put a lot of thought into. Thank you!