Been thinking a lot about the state of organizing in the US Empire, and increasingly I’ve come to the conclusion that the main 2 options for anyone organizing are either the DSA while joining an explicitly ML caucus (at the moment Red Star) with the “DSA as the incubator for the vanguard, not the vanguard itself” strategy, or PSL. Starting a new org is tremendously difficult, and will likely come from a split from another org, rather than growing from a study circle like Red Clarion proposes.
Joining the DSA and an ML caucus is like a microcosm of being in the PSL, just narrowing your exposure largely to radicalized workers. The DSA is where the radicalized liberals flock to, not the PSL. This has tremendous advantage in terms of exposure, but you deal with the DSA’s paper membership. The 130,000 members the DSA promotes sound incredible on paper, until you realize that there is no commitment requirements to speak of. Nevertheless, an ML faction within the org has the ability to steer the org in a more correct direction and perhaps can form the basis of either a split from the DSA, or a new center to purge the reformists and force them to split. In either case, it isn’t a strategy without historic basis.
The PSL is a weak ML org. It has problems with the structure and adherance of democratic centralism, and has rapidly grown in the last couple of years to its own detriment, as the party seemed ill-equipped to handle this influx. There are problems with how discipline is handled, and the strategy for recruitment is a high bar, as it is a cadre org. Nevertheless, it is far more theoretically correct than the DSA could hope to be without the aforementioned purge of reformists, and at the present moment I have more faith in their ability to improve as an organization thanks to their cadre approach than I do the DSA to become a good org.
An org is its members, no matter how good or bad the structures you create are in theory, you need the highest level cadre to execute good structures well and mitigate the problems of weak structures. The primary weaknesses of the PSL can be overcome from within, I believe, by virtue of being a cadre org, than the DSA can by being a mass org. I might be proven wrong in the coming years, but this is historically why cadre orgs even exist in the first place, and Red Star Caucus has a long way to go to transition the DSA to an ML org.
The main tasks of the Statesian MLs are to build up cadre, and build up organization within the working class. Membership is fragmented. I expect either the DSA to split or the PSL to overtake them, and any ML should be watching the movement carefully. There could even be a new org that gains in membership quickly, like the Trotskyist RCI, only with an ML line. However, this is not that moment. This is the time before a vanguard has formed, and thus it’s our job to gain as much organizing experience as possible and front the most correct lines as possible, with careful attention to settler-colonialism as is often neglected.
CPUSA is thoroughly compromised and reformist. FRSO has been a tiny org for decades and minimizes settlers colonialism. Unlike the DSA, the CPUSA is too small the party incubation strategy to make any coherent sense, it’s weaker than the DSA as a reformist org and weaker than the PSL as a demcent org. It’s the worst of both worlds. Therefore, any communist should look to see the status of their local DSA and PSL, depending on which strategy you believe most advances your own organizing skills and your ability to advance a correct ML line to the radicalized working class.
I wish I had a definitive answer at this time, but there isn’t a vanguard. In the aftermath of the midterm elections, most of the energy is in the DSA, which invites new opportunity for communists to expose the working class to a correct understanding of theory and practice. However, this energy can quickly fizzle out as the DSA is not a cadre org and is reformist, so this moment in particular should fade. Where we go from there depends on the ever-shifting landscape.
Thoughts?
I have several questions for you:
- Why do you think that a new organization will not develop from a study circle like Red Clarion has stated?
- What historical precedent is there for the strategy you mentioned for the Marxist caucus?
- You mention that the Marxist caucus is not pursuing a strategy of turning the DSA into a vanguard, but then you mention later on that “Red Star Caucus has a long way to go to transition the DSA to an ML org”, which is strange when you admitted to the DSA being a magnet for radical liberals and also mentioned their incubation strategy: Could you clarify?
As for my personal thoughts, I am doubtful that the PSL could really develop into anything revolutionary if what was written about them is true (content warning for mention of sexual abuse: https://clarion.unity-struggle-unity.org/2026-06-16-the-psl-letters/): Poor leadership seems to be a significant issue. I also am unsure if the Marxist caucus in DSA will go anywhere, since I do not know much about them.
Regarding point 1, it’s unlikely, not impossible. The problem faced by communists in the US Empire is not a lack of reading, but a lack of organization. Theory is certainly under-studied, but there are plenty of well-read communists. The primary obstacle therefore isn’t necessarily to rediscover a new correct line and grow from there, but to develop the organizational skills of the theoretically developed, and expand this to the rest of the working class.
Regarding point 2, as I understand it communist parties have often sprung from larger united fronts. The Bolsheviks were essentially a faction within the Russian Social Democratic Party, before their transformation into the CPSU.
Regarding point 3, I mean that the “party incubation strategy” essentially refers to creating a correct line within a mass org in order to create the conditions for a large cadre org. It doesn’t necessarily mean turning the DSA into an ML org, but having a large, correct ML org come from within the DSA. The Caucuses therefore serve the purpose of a political advisory to the entire party as the basis of radicalized liberals turned potential communists.
Regarding the PSL’s leadership, there are certainly problems, but the PSL is not a Trotskyist org like USU alleges, and does in fact have the capacity to change. Their structures of democratic centralism may not be the most solid, and leadership desparately needs some revitalization from the rank and file, but they still are far more effective at creating cadre than the other options.
Overall, though, I’m mostly seeking other thoughts. I don’t have a firm backing on any of these points, these are observations I have made and I want to see what other comrades may have to offer.
How exactly do communists develop organizational skills? That was an aspect of theory and practice that I never understood well.
I do not think the Russian Social Democratic Party was a united front (I thought it was a party that eventually developed two opposed factions that eventually split apart), so the comparison is not exactly correct.
Could you elaborate on the part about the caucuses being a “political advisory to the entire party”?
I have never heard of the PSL being called Trotskyist (the issues USU points out are mostly based upon opportunism and other things). Also, from what I have read, their cover-ups of sexual abuse are a massive issue, and in the link I gave, the leadership issues might be worse than what you say.
Communists develop organizational skills by working in a political organization. We have to roll up our sleeves and actually build up the skills to manage, direct, lead, follow, plan, develop logistics, and more. These are taught practically.
United Front was a bit of a misnomer on my part. The RSDP was a big-tent party, and the Bolsheviks eventually came to form their own correct party, and then the CPSU.
The DSA has groups within it that have few members, but stand on the highest leading body. They are like formally recognized interest groups that steer the party in different directions, though the DSA is loosely organized and has a ton of regional autonomy, which is why Zionist chapters like LA and NYC are allowed to go against national declarations. They lack binding power.
As for USU, while sometimes they make good points, they have issues of their own. The main writer has a fragile ego and lashes out at everyone else, having run a failed political party and being accused of misogyny himself. PSL definitely has leadership issues, I’m not denying that, but that doesn’t mean these problems are impossible to solve and grow beyond. I think you need to keep USU’s perspective in mind, their best work is precisely the writing that doesn’t involve other Statesian organizations.
More than that, what do you believe is the correct path? I’m writing this post not to hear myself speak, but because I want to know the thoughts of others. Like I said, I’m not especially firm in the thoughts I jotted down above, and am seeking alternative viewpoints to sharpen my own and help me reconsider. There’s mountains to critique about every Statesian org, unfortunately, but is there a best path at the moment?
The charge of anger issues and misogyny is quite the extreme one, so it would be appreciated if you gave a source for that claim. Also, I thought the USU was theoretically sound in its writings.
PSL’s issues are fundamentally structural, and I do not expect the PSL to be able to resolve the contradiction between the common member and the leaders at the top (alongside other contradictions) without serious and rather unrealistic changes to the party as a whole. Honestly, I think a splintering of the party as a whole is more likely than it actually becoming a vanguard of the proletariat.
The best path (and the most realistic one in my opinion) would be for a fledgling Marxist organization with democratic centralism and principled Marxist positions to root themself in a community, spread themself outwards to other places, and then slowly build itself up more in terms of experience and resources. There is also the chance that the Red Star Caucus could take the mantle of vanguardism if it ever separates itself from the DSA, but I need to read more on them to know for sure. I see no future in any of the big four (CPUSA, PSL, FRSO, and DSA) that has them as the vanguard, but I must admit that my position on them all is based on what USU has written on them, so I am not quite as informed on the matter as I would like.
Of course, the creation of a Marxist organization is difficult, but I think it is more realistic that one crops up in response to the ever-increasingly severe contradictions of American settler-colonialism and capitalism rather than expecting parties with histories of numerous fundamental issues to resolve those issues. I am just a person in debt at the end of the day though, so take it with a gram of peppermint :D
Regarding USU, here’s the thread I recommend. USU is frequently correct, but like FRSO, they seem to be incapable of expanding beyond a tiny subset, and for a group that recommends people start from the literal smallest unit, this seems to spell a lack of correct theory on the necessary tasks for the Statesian communist movement. They still produce good theory, I think their guide to forming a new party is pretty good! But at the same time they have ego involved in how they portray other groups.
As for the PSL, I’m aware of their issues, both real and alleged. I’ve read the articles from USU and the letters from those that have left it. I still think it has the ability to grow for the better, and I believe this to be more likely than a new party being formed from the study circle onward. I may be wrong, and don’t wish to minimize their real issues, but at the same time I am highly skeptical of the viability of forming an entirely new org. This seems detached from the primary necessity at the moment, which is rectifying the total disorganization of the proletariat and the radicals among us.
I think, what I’m seeing, is a conflict between the desire for a truly great organization and the reality of the relatively disappointing orgs that exist today. It can be easy to say we need a new one, but how does that form? Are any of us in such a micro-pre party?
The question of new party vs. existing reminds me a little of programmers looking at code and going:
“This code is awful. I’m going to rewrite it.”
later
“There is a lot more to this than I thought. Also, I see better why they were doing things the way they were now.”
That’s not to say orgs can’t have foundational problems. Like a codebase, they can and sometimes starting over is the best idea. But it’s also easy to look from the outside and assume the issue is incompetence, rather than complexity of the process and grappling with limitations.
I don’t really have a confident answer in the specifics myself, but it is a question that matters, new vs. existing. It might be there are organizers who can do way better than PSL from the ground up, but it also may take them 10+ years just to get it to a place where it has that good foundation built and is doing enough to be relevant politically. Or they might start out with one strategy and then find it’s not doing much, and have to pivot, losing time on that.
At any rate, I’m glad you bring it up. One thing is for sure is that none of us have infinite time, either as individuals or to be ready as a vanguard to move things toward socialism instead of some kind of collapse or neo-nazi power grab or something. Already with ICE and surveillance and so on, the framework is being put in place to crack down against an unhappy population, on a larger scale than the US’s usual of targeted racism. People are pushing back to a degree, I’m not saying it’s some kind of inevitability, but the conditions are increasingly in a place where stability is far from guaranteed. So any decision people are looking at in terms of organizing, I do think they should be considering just how much time they probably have to make something happen before things get a lot worse; and if/when things do get a lot worse, what organizing in that landscape looks like and what possible changes to existing tactics are needed.
I guess the TL;DR of the point I’m trying to make is, it may be less about what people potentially could do and what they have time to do right now in the current conditions.
Those are great points, thanks for sharing!
To be honest, the evidence regarding the USU being led by such a person is lacking (I understand that obscure communists do not exactly have a lot of documentation to their name, but I am still doubtful of the very pointed accusations shown in that thread). Also, even if what was said about the main writer is true, they are not the only ones that publish articles to the site (as far as I know), so they would not be entirely representative of all articles on there.
I think we will have to accept that we disagree on the PSL changing in a positive way, unless you consider a splinter faction with principled Marxist takes manifesting as changing in a positive way: Perhaps a faction split off from one of the four parties can develop into such a thing, since it would take some of the members from a somewhat known organization towards a more principled direction without starting from scratch, and they could focus on organizing the proletariat quickly.
I think that a party forms to deal with contradictions of capitalism from the local to national level, but the issue is the fact that America is a neoimperial power based on settler-colonialism, so the labor aristocracy (espcially white workers in that group) and some of the petty-bourgeoisie would more likely flock to the four major communist parties mentioned before, because they would rather reform the system to their benefit than destroy it at the expense of their neoimperial privilege. A Marxist-Leninist party must not base itself on the petty-bourgeoisie or labor aristocracy if it ever hopes to resolve the contradictions of capitalism, but on what is typically understood as the non-aristocratic proletariat: The result otherwise would be opportunism, reformism, revisionism, etc.
Edit: Do you think a more principled faction splitting off is more likely than the PSL changing for the better? And what do you think about what I said regarding how a Marxist-Leninist party should base itself?
Sure, on this we have to understand that the primacy of the settler-colonial nature of the US, we must form a party focused on the oppressed nations, especially indigenous. PSL is, among communist organizations in the US, the least bad on this one. FRSO rejects settler-colonialism in the US, as USU points out, and the DSA doesn’t have a strong pro-indigenous line. The PSL recognizes the right of nations to self-determination, including secession, and primarily recruits from oppressed nations (though many Euro-settler workers also join).
Again, I need to stress that I’m not a ride-or-die PSL fan or anything, I just do not see a rising local party turning empire-wide. I’m not trying to dismiss the people trying, I have just seen no success on that front yet. Perhaps I’m just blind to it, but is the answer really that every communist should focus primarily on forming study groups when the primary issue is a lack of organization? Am I mistaken on the primary issue, or am I mistaken on the rectification of it?
If we’re talking American electoralism, I think DSA is on it’s way to becoming a minority bloc in the Democratic party and may eventually coup or supplant the party. The last ten years of elections have demonstrated that Democrats cannot win without participation from their left flank. It’s time the flank start making demands and weeding out the problem Dems.
Dsa needs to develop party lines that the voters hold elected officials accountable to (ex: Medicare for all, no aid to Israel, abolish ice, prosecute trump, whatever). The risk here is the inevitable liberalizing of these policies (abolish the police --> defund the police --> fund the police) so the people will need to be radicalized by the party so they are motivated to hold officials accountable.
Appreciate the opportunity to share, though it’s intimidating to attempt to have something to say in a cowbee thread
Why is it intimidating? 🫠
In any case, I think the reformist route is a dead end, so the most useful aspects of a reformist org are in recruiting to a revolutionary org while demonstrating the futility of reformism.
Coming from Brazil, this is true: reformism is a dead end. But, what we’ve learned is that, properly put in perspective, electoralism can serve as a platform, although restricted.
For example, local elections are somewhat easy to win. Look at Mandani. The problem, I believe, is how easily he takes a more individualizing approach (“I did something good because there were individuals/groups asking”, rather than “X group needs Y policy because of Z problems that higher the rungs of the government couldn give two shits”). Making the situations less bad is good. The problem is that it’s defanging.
Not only that, his whole ethos is “compromise so we can govern”, so this will destroy everything. If a local politician could enable the people like “yeah, you know what? Fuck Big Tech” openly, it sure helps the masses feel a little more comfortable to protest Big Tech. And then, finally, the Party can better educate, coordinate and amass these people.
We, from the Brazillian left, are taking this lessons to heart, since the socdem vacuum kills. Try to learn this. Organize, plan on running elections if needed. Shit, even in China very little of the population is in the Party.
Yep! Social democracy is having a resurgance, and we need to find out how to properly oppose its dead-end tendencies while also leveraging the fact that many people support it because of the energy behind it right now, without alienating them. Thanks!
Intimidating because Profe already knows the answers to the questions he asks, he’s testing if I know the answer. And even if he doesn’t know the answer, he’s forgotten more books on the subject than I’ve read.
Okay, take my previous post to it’s logical conclusion: 10 years in, the dsa caucus fails to wrestle any meaningful concessions from the Democrats, which indicates reform is a dead end (we are here). The American political system cannot be “fixed,” it is working as intended. By this time, if they were doing their job, DSA organizers have radicalized workers in professions the can call strikes (longshoremen refuse to work at ports that serve ships bound for the entity; the IBEW refuses to work on data centers or ICE contracts; teamsters refuse to transport certain materials, etc).
I dunno, I’m not hopeful for the American future. We’re going to be rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic every 2 years while the country and planet burn
No testing, and no, not a professor, I genuinely want to hear how people see the situation because I don’t really have a firm opinion I stand by.
In any case, the DSA likely could produce a vanguard from within it, either as a purge or a split, but it depends on those within and outside the DSA.
It would take balancing situational awareness with radicalizing, and ultimately a split, IMO. I don’t even think there’s a chapter of DSA, CPUSA, or PSL chapter within two hours driving from me.
That’s also sadly the case for many people.
The last ten years of elections have demonstrated that Democrats cannot win without participation from their left flank.
All the more reason that one of the primary tasks of anyone working within the DSA should be to cut the connection to the Democrats.
Here’s papa Stalin taking your observation to its logical conclusion:
Fascism is the bourgeoisie’s fighting organisation that relies on the active support of Social-Democracy. Social-Democracy is objectively the moderate wing of fascism. There is no ground for assuming that the fighting organisation of the bourgeoisie can achieve decisive successes in battles, or in governing the country, without the active support of Social-Democracy. There is just as little ground for thinking that Social-Democracy can achieve decisive successes in battles, or in governing the country, without the active support of the fighting organisation of the bourgeoisie. These organisations do not negate, but supplement each other. They are not antipodes, they are twins. Fascism is an informal political bloc of these two chief organisations; a bloc, which arose in the circumstances of the post-war crisis of imperialism, and which is intended for combating the proletarian revolution. The bourgeoisie cannot retain power without such a bloc. It would therefore be a mistake to think that “pacifism” signifies the liquidation of fascism. In the present situation, “pacifism” is the strengthening of fascism with its moderate, Social-Democratic wing pushed into the forefront.
(emphasis mine)
https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1924/09/20.htm
it seems to me, looking in from outside, that the psl has a huge leadership problem right now. if it doesn’t oust most or all of its central committee, it’s going to do more and more damage to itself as time goes on. i’ve been saying this a lot in the past week, but i don’t think they have the correct line on elections either.
i disagree that these small local branches have no value. i’m not convinced there’s a single good CPUSA anywhere in the US, but other small orgs can certainly do good work. at a time when no clear vanguard has arisen, it makes sense to organize with whoever is doing good work where you are, even if they’re not DSA or PSL.
completely unrelated but i didn’t want to write a whole new comment. where has the USU said PSL is a trot org? seems a bit of an odd claim for them to make.
For clarity, I don’t mean to say local branches have no value. Everyone needs to judge their own local conditions. As for USU and their position on PSL, this is what they say in their Unity Prospectus:
Many of the Trotskyist organizations, such as PSL, have fallen prey to the same deviations: they have created unassailable central organizing positions which are not accountable to any democratic process, and then held these positions tightly. Whether, like the revisionists, this began as a means of ideological control, it has developed into a system that is resistant to change and to growth.
They maintain that it descends from the WWP and carries over WWP’s Trotskyist roots, which IMO is an idealist reach. Marcy upheld the Soviet line on Hungary, and from then on WWP was gradually more ML, and PSL from its inception as a split from WWP has essentially had widespread ML membership, upholding Stalin and AES. This is why I think there’s a bit of inter-org bad-faith going on in that assessment.
Given that the DSA is a massive tent organization, the potential for “recruiting” or agitating a subsection of that party with Marxist-Leninist political theory could probably yield some merits. It’s hard to ignore the DSA, as it has been increasingly gaining more of a following. If the party mobilizes the rank and file regularly, then teaching the party members with the most revolutionary potential would be something of great significance since these folks have actual organizing experience. Reaching the type of party members who have a knack for organizing and reaching others would be of paramount significance. Just some of my thoughts. I don’t have any experience in organized politics, since I’m fairly new to Marxist-Leninist political theory and I was very much one of those “radical liberals” that despised the Republicans, had an ever-growing hate for the Democrat Party and a thorough hatred for the American imperialist regime and its American politics.
It is & was more important to build the logistics and the infrastructure of a vanguard party than to fixate on converting everyone. The structure to accommodate a large influx of new members, which is now the case, should’ve been built in 2016, but I understand that the political culture back then was more concerned with debating whether Trump is fascist or not. Not to imply I was better than the rest, I was not sure myself and my socialist educational progress was much less advanced than it is now.
Good point!
I personally think agitating within the DSA is wasted energy, as its structure as a reformist / socdem party makes it impossible to be anything more than the left flank supporting and “getting out the vote” for democrats. These parties cannot be turned left, regardless of how many individual members might do so, and years of energy of good comrades have been wasted trying to do just that.
We have historical blueprints of how socdem / soft left parties mishandle every opportunity: DSA will eventually get their chance in the sun, and they will fail miserably, leaving people to look further left.
PSL’s politics are solid, but I agree that the way they practice demcent leaves something to be desired. Hopefully that will get better with time, as the party has so solid members. Personally I think its the best option for US comrades, as starting yet another party from scratch would be a herculean effort.
Yea, the DSA would only serve, if anything, as a meeting space for revolutionaries frustrated with the DSA, to form a new party. It would be like starting an org, but among comrades that already work together. Thanks for the input!
For sure, no probs!
One other thing I thought of: while of course communism will of course win on a global scale (we might even be in a stalingrad moment right now with China overtaking the US on more and more metrics), we have to be realistic about the time-scale.
The US is the imperial center, and will likely be the very last country to start moving down the communist path. As far as regions, it will likely be Asia (India probably last), Africa, ME, Latin america, then eastern europe, southern europe, northern europe, then north america dead last.
We’re citizens not of one country, but of the world, and we should focus our efforts and energies where they will have the most benefit. I believe you are doing an important part of the media battle being waged on the english-speaking internet; enlightening, educating, and fighting the good fight against imperialist narratives and the people that mindlessly follow them. That fight has positive repercussions for not just the US, but for anyone who reads english and stumbles upon this alternative platform. The fediverse is largely turning into a battlefield between liberals/imperialists and communists, and its a space we should not let liberals have.
Of course I don’t mean to detract from US comrades doing the solid work of organizing, but its worth noting that when empires fall, they usually are hollowed out long before, then are conquered from without. Ancient Rome for example had less than 1% of its peak population when it was finally conquered. Even though the US political system seems like its unraveling quickly, US capital still rules, and bonaparts will emerge for probably a hundred years or more, who will fight to preserve US capitalism even in spite of its short-term self-destructive thinking, just like ancient rome had a historical period of military dictators, whose desires were completely de-coupled from the general population.
Most US comrades are aware of those material conditions, and know our job at this point is just educating, and showing up for anti-imperialist protests when we can.
Yep, it’s sad but you’re likely correct. I appreciate, of course, the kind words. I think my stance towards revolutionary optimism still makes me feel like history doesn’t have to go down that route. Not just for the people on Turtle Island, but ending the empire quicker would be an enormous weight off of the world. I know I have to set my expectations soberly, but I can’t act with the assumption that the fight can’t be won faster than that, if only because I can’t convince others of a better world being necessary and possible if I can’t also convince them that it’s possible within a human lifetime.
Haven’t heard that frso downplays settler colonialism. Can you help me understand where that claim comes from? I’d like to investigate it further.
I generally agree with USU in this article.
Reading through the original article, I think I heard folks near me express contention over this author’s work. I will continue with a special eye to the topic. Thank you for sharing!
No problem!





