Genuine questions.

What’s up with China’s history of backing reactionary forces and siding with the us against socialist countries/projects?

  • Why did China back and support the Khmer Rouge alongside the US to fight Vietnam?

  • Why did China back and support the Mujahadeen alongside the US to fight the communists of Afghanistan and the Soviet Union?

  • Why did China back and support the FNLA and UNITA alongside the US to fight the MPLA and the Cubans in Angola?

I’m fairly ignorant of all these so I’m asking for clarification on the subjects as well as personal opinions.

  • REEEEvolution@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    7 days ago
    1. Vietnam was keeping supplies intended for the Rouge for itself during the vietnam war, kicked out its chinese minority, was making noise on the back then informal China-Vietnam border, sided with the soviets during the split(Vietnam didn’t really have a choice), upheld the claims of South Vietnam on the SCS after unification and invaded Cambodia (Vietnam already knew of the genocides of the Rouge, China didn’t). To China it looked as if they had a growing Vietnamese empire to their south allied to the now hostile USSR to their north. The PRC needed a counter weight. Ultimately China settled staying in a border war with Vietnam until the 80s to fuck them economically, it was shitshow for both sides. Both communist parties have mended ties only recently and the vietnamese people are still pissed.

    2. Sino-Soviet-Split.

    3. Sino-Soviet-Split

    • “vietnamese empire” is a ludicrous term, one that should have died with pol pot in the jungles of cambodia.

      this line of “thinking”, if one can even call it that, stems from a mixture of khmer rouge delusions, cia propaganda and the chinese government conjuring up justifications for its conduct.

      vietnam at the time was a beggarly poor nation, sanctioned to hell and back and deeply wounded by war and imperialist aggression. and after all this, it still managed to do humanity another favour by toppling the khmer rouge régime, which was supported by the united states on the initiative of that rotten ghoul and good friend of china henry kissinger and was used by western capital to force hanoi into yet another conflict, in order to further impoverish it and deny it any peaceful development. also, i seriously doubt that china did not know of the khmer rouge’s conduct. the two governments had extensive relations, and the chinese ministry of state security are competent people. at the very least, china’s leadership was aware of the findings of the 1979 tribunal, since its media (along with western outlets) went on to deride them as “show trials” and insisted on the innocence of those found guilty.

      afterwards, china was complicit in conducting vietnam’s diplomatic isolation, mainly through its role in the creation of the sham “coalition government of democratic kampuchea” which was installed at the un on washington’s behest and had the sole purpose of voting the way america needed it to, conducting anti-communist propaganda speeches and laundering money for the khmer rouge and allied forces, but also through various other initiatives to isolate and damage vietnam economically and diplomatically.

      thinking that it had brought vietnam to a point where it could no longer effectively resist, china launched an illegal, unjustified and unprovoked invasion of vietnam, with the full knowledge and support of the white house, as later confirmed by that other wretched ghoul, anti-communist war criminal zbigniew brzeziński. just look at these quotes of deng xiaoping during his visit to us president jimmy carter:

      china needs to teach vietnam a lesson

      the little child is getting naughty; it’s time it gets spanked

      do they sound like something a fraternal socialist nation should say?

      the invasion was condemned by most socialist or anti-imperialist nations worth their salt, including socialist afghanistan, angola, benin, bulgaria, the congo, cuba, czechoslovakia, east germany, ethiopia, hungary, mongolia, mozambique, poland, south yemen and even albania. laos also urged china to withdraw troops. though, of course, western and chinese propaganda went on to falsely paint all of them as “soviet satellite states”, even the ones the prc had cordial relations with.

      the invasion meanwhile led to many unnecessary deaths, displacement, and vietnam suffering destruction of homes, roads, bridges, rail links, farms, and border trade routes. repair costs and lost production added strain to the already weak economy. this was one of the reasons why the đổi mới reforms came to be seen unavoidable necessity.

      all this simply because china wanted to be the top bully in service of their buddies in the united states and thus couldn’t tolerate a strong and independent neighbour.

      • REEEEvolution@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        7 days ago

        Bud I explained Chinas opinion. To the PRC it initally looked like a expanding Vietnam to their south allied to the USSR to their north. Both opposed to China via their positioning in the Split. China was wrong regarding its analysis regarding the invasion of Cambodia. Take your personal attacks somewhere else.

        all this simply because china wanted to be the top bully in service of their buddies in the united states and thus couldn’t tolerate a strong and independent neighbour.

        Ironically what you wrote is the Vietnamese propaganda on the matter. Which unmasked as obvious bullshit once you remember how much China aided the Vietminh against the french and yanks. Easy example: Chinese versions of the AK were directly handed to Vietnam, the PLA got theirs years later. Definitely something someone wanting to be the top bully who could not tolerate a strong and independent neighbour would do!

        I explained the things Vietnam fucked up. China had some valid reasons for its actions, as did Vietnam. But both also fucked up hard at various points. Thus culminated in the shitshow that was the invasion. I have no idea who fucked up more before that, so do not try to believe I said both did equally, please.

        But the idea that Vietnam was some innocent chungus holy country that did nothing wrong is unmaterialistic thinking. Before sopcialist nations are socialist, they are nations.

        • the united states has shared military technologies much more advanced than assault rifles with all sorts of countries. does that mean that washington has no intention of being the top bully and is willing to tolerate a strong and independent neighbour?

          also, it is rather strange of you to criticise me for being insufficiently critical of the vietnamese narrative, while portraying beijing’s claims of “vietnamese empire building” as if they were valid concerns and not obvious smoke and mirrors to drum up justification for the war. imperialism requires a capitalist economy, which vietnam did not possess, and also it did not export capital and was not under the control of a financial oligarchy.

          vietnam was not a threat to china in any meaningful way; simple economic, military and demographic statistics show as much. and simultaneously, china at the time was rather reluctant to antagonise american hegemony and actual imperialism…

          • the rizzler@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            6 days ago

            that vietnam was soviet-aligned after the sino-soviet split meant that china was concerned it was about to be totally surrounded by soviet-aligned countries. the issue was not a “vietnamese empire”, the issue was the sino-soviet split. these are some of the most complex issues of the 20th century, and framing it as a simple issue of “bullying” is reductionist moralism.

                • you’re sounding like a reaganite.

                  there was no “soviet bloc” as such. while there were many pro-soviet governments around the world, this was due to the ussr supporting anti-colonial movements and socialist revolutions worldwide, in turn leading to states wrongly dubbed “soviet satellites” by western and chinese propaganda. meanwhile, the only allies willing to fight for the prc were reactionary clanists like siyaad barre, compradores like jonas savimbi, misogynist drug barons such as gulbeddin hekmatyar, and monsters like pol pot.

                  your view relies solely on uncritically accepting chinese leadership’s claims about the ussr, despite all no evidence supporting them.

                  also, you didn’t answer my question:

                  what supposed military threat the prc was experiencing from vietnam?

                  • the rizzler@lemmygrad.ml
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    0
                    ·
                    6 days ago

                    it’s great to say now with the benefit of hindsight that the soviet union likely wouldn’t have invaded china. that’s probably true. but china had just spent a century being carved up by various imperial powers, and it was now experiencing aggression (both real and imagined) from another superpower. the soviets had just massively overreacted to yugoslavia (see below). then, they massively overreacted to chinese opposition to certain soviet policies (see below), essentially attempting to kill the chinese nuclear program, even burning documents related to all sorts of projects in china. so with afghanistan, the dprk, and vietnam all aligning themselves with the ussr, yes, they felt threatened. the cpv was in thailand, and it’s important in that sense to remember that it was started as the communist party of indochina. if vietnam had united indochina, that would surround china entirely. then, vietnam had “mistreated” the ethnic chinese minority along the border. this generated the fear that there was, indeed, an attempt to encircle china, as the russian empire had attempted during the century of humiliation.

                    of course, from the perspective of the vietnamese communists, there wasn’t a soviet bloc. they were forced to pick sides, and they ended up not picking china. then, china massively overreacted by supporting pol pot’s fascist regime. it also filled me with a sense of disgust to hear deng xiaoping compare it to spanking children or something. as for the minorities, they were offered citizenship for the first time in vietnamese history. certainly, chauvinism can’t be eliminated in a day, not in vietnam and not anywhere. the vietnamese soldiers who sacrificed everything to end the murderous khmer rouge are the heroes of this story for sure, insofar as there are heroes. it was a huge mistake for china to support the khmer rouge. but that doesn’t make china the villain.

                    at the end of the day, denouncing any country involved in the sino-soviet split (besides maybe democratic kampuchea) as a “bully” is nothing but idealist moralism. the sino-soviet split was likely the most genuinely complex geopolitical issue of the 20th century and to reduce it in that way is just silly.

                    below:

                    In the early postwar period, serious disagreements emerged between the Yugoslav and Soviet communist parties over a number of issues: the establishment of a stable peace in Europe, the possibilities for supporting the communist side in the Greek Civil War, and the economic mechanisms of building socialism in Eastern Europe. Whichever side was right or wrong in the initial disagreements, the Soviet leadership responded to Yugoslavia’s assertion of independence in a heavy-handed way that this served to inspire distrust of the USSR.

                    The Soviets, in March 1948, began taking strong sanctions against Yugoslavia. On March 18 all Soviet military advisers were withdrawn, and on March 19 all economic advisers. An embargo was placed on trade with Yugoslavia by the Soviet Union and all the other socialist countries. This threatened the collapse of the Yugoslav economy, which was heavily dependent on trade with the East European countries because of the West’s hostility to recent Yugoslav nationalisations and the friendly relations since 1945 among the East European countries. The Yugoslav Communist Party was expelled from the world communist movement and its leaders compared to fascists. Leading communists were put on trial throughout Eastern Europe and charged with treason for being Titoists. The Soviets also tried to overthrow Tito’s leadership inside his own country by supporting alternative leadership within the Yugoslav Party. Although never carried out, the Soviets also made threats of military intervention against Yugoslavia.

                    Yugoslavia was by no means an insignificant country, and Tito and the Yugoslav Communist Party had earned enormous respect around the world for their heroic defence against Nazi occupation. Tito had been known to many European communists and anti-fascists before World War II, when he managed the Paris centre recruiting anti-fascist volunteers to fight in the Spanish Civil War. The Yugoslavs’ sudden expulsion from the Information Bureau of the Communist and Workers’ Parties (which had been established in 1947 in order to coordinate actions between communist parties, and which ironically had its headquarters in Belgrade) and the severe measures taken against it shocked many people in the west European parties.

                    The unity of the world communist movement was even more profoundly shaken by the Sino-Soviet split, which started to quietly emerge in 1957 and which by the early 1960s became a full-scale ideological conflict. Initially, Mao Zedong and his comrades had cautiously welcomed Khrushchev’s policies of destalinisation and peaceful coexistence; but from 1957, driven in part by a resentment of Soviet hegemonism and in part by their own turn towards a more radical domestic agenda (particularly the Great Leap Forward, which represented a major break with the economic programme proposed by the Soviets), they started to voice their opposition to these policies. The Soviets once again over-reacted to the questioning of their authority over the global communist movement, and punished China by unilaterally withdrawing their (thousands of) advisers and by criticising Chinese ultra-leftism in international forums. The Chinese side took to increasingly bitter polemics against Soviet revisionism, and actively challenging the USSR’s leadership of the global communist movement.

                    - Why doesn’t the Soviet Union exist any more?, part 3

    • LeninZedong@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      7 days ago

      I am a bit suspicious of the slanted portrayal of Vietnam (could you provide sources); the positive portrayal of China is also suspicious to me.

      • REEEEvolution@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        7 days ago

        Sorry, I came to those conclusions at various points. Deng was pretty open why he was pissed with Vietnam, for example. I think in the interview he did with that anglo reporter he said it at some point.

        As for the SCS stuff, you can go digging when that pub brawl began. Been a while since I did it.

        And most importantly: When two former long-time close allies end up at war with each other and one side claims to be completely without fault (Vietnams line), that’s suspicious. That’s war propaganda 101 “we are without fault, out enemy attacked without reason!”