We know that Jupiter and Saturn are made mostly of helium and hydrogen, but is this true for other systems and their gas giants too?
uhm so my perspective is that:
gas clouds aren’t stable if they’re too small. the cutoff limit for this is somewhere around 10²¹ kg, if i calculated correctly, so a bit less than the size of the Earth (10²⁴ kg). (this depends on temperature somewhat, but only a little bit).
basically, below that mass, the pressure of the gas is larger than the gravity, and the gas expands and vanishes into the surrounding space. it does not form a planet.
to form a planet, you need a solid rock (like an asteroid) that is large enough (10²¹ kg) to act as a seed, such that a gas cloud can attach to it and remain stable. this will then further increase the mass of the object, and it grows as a planet.
that’s why, in our solar system, NO object below a mass of roughly 10²² kg has an atmosphere(!!). mars is slightly above that (10²³ kg) and has a very thin atmosphere (6 mbar average pressure at surface level). Earth has around 10²⁴ kg and has thin atmosphere (1 bar at surface, still low compared to total mass of planet). Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune each have a massive atmosphere that makes for a large part of the whole object’s mass. And so does the sun.
So, to add detail to your napkin math, there’s also solar wind to consider. That would be why you came out to 1021 kg, while little Titan, an order of magnitude bigger, is the first thing that has much in the way of atmosphere.
For general astrophysics, I suspect you might not have been including a big enough temperature range for your gas cloud, as well. The entire milky way is a gas cloud, but because it’s at tens of thousands to millions of degrees, it only slowly condenses into stars. Obviously, that doesn’t apply to our solar system’s planets, though!
Most of the universe is hydrogen.
I don’t know if we can tell reliably (yet) what exoplanets are made of, but generally the assumption is that our solar system is chemically typical, so we extrapolate that for other star systems.
We actually can, from stellar transits!
Some of them are pretty weird. Molten silica clouds and rain come immediately to mind.
I’ve seen things you people wouldn’t believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate.
Will all those moments be lost in time?
Most matter is hydrogen but then, supposedly, there is dark matter and dark energy 😯 !
There is a new model that I read about the other day that avoids the need for dark matter/energy and extends the age of the universe.
I’ve always (armchair astro physicist) thought that the dark matter/energy was always just a fudge to fit an ill-fitting model to observations (which isn’t inherently wrong). It just means the model is wrong.
There’s a new MOND model every couple of years. They never work. I wouldn’t get excited.
That’s not really true though. There are multiple lines of evidence. We can calculate the mass, we see the effects through gravitational lensing, there’s the CMB evidence etc. And we can’t forget the bullet cluster, which has a different distribution of dark matter, showing that most theories that make some global changes to physics such as MOND cannot be true.
This is way more than fudge factor. Everything is consistent with a something that doesn’t interact except through gravity.
As for dark energy, this very question was covered in a podcast that you might be interested in listening to. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-daniel-and-kellys-extraord-29862087/episode/is-dark-energy-a-fudge-factor-343402032/
That evidence is not evidence of dark matter (that’s the problem), it’s evidence that we’ve modeled gravity or spacetime or inertia or whatever wrong.
It’s like drawing triangles on spheres or other non euclidean spaces, but for mass/inertia. Maybe the problem with the Hubble constant is the clue.
If you need a big fat invisible undetectable magic amount of mass or energy to make it all work, perhaps some of the underlying assumptions are incorrect.
It might be a big fat invisible undetectable magic amount of mass or energy, but it’s not the only option. It is an inelegant option.
How can any change to gravity globally accurately describe the bullet cluster? I’ve never seen a MOND theory even try to do that. They keep talking about galaxy rotation and forget all the other lines of evidence.
There is a lot of evidence that motion and gravitational lensing at the scale of galaxies doesn’t behave how we would expect from the mass we see and relativity.
The obvious solutions there are:
- There is mass we don’t see And/or
- Our models of gravity aren’t fully correct
Dark matter is the theory with the most support, but there are plenty of problems with it as well. For one, we’d need the majority of the matter in the universe to be dark, and we have essentially no theory for what it would be. Obviously no way to ‘see’ it, and no way to detect it beyond gravitational effects. Any theory that relies on the presence of an absolutely massive amount of invisible and conveniently distributed stuff is going to face challenges.
MOND has also faced trouble, no theory here has accounted for all observations.
We must also remain open to the possibility that some observations are true evidence for an unknown massive particle, and some are the result of an incorrect understanding of gravity.
There appears to be quite some debate between several competing theories.
Apparently MOND can explain that cluster with ‘only’ additional cold hydrogen.
The authors of the paper this article is talking about graded their own work. These are the model’s builders testing it with their own code. An outside group checked it against 32 independent expansion-rate measurements and concluded it faces significant challenges…
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/547/3/stag430/8507252
I get people wanna jump to different explanations for DE and DM, but it needs to fit all the data points already gathered and organized into a theory to be a better explanation than ∆CDM model. No one is saying ∆CDM is perfect or absolutely fully correct or the final answer, just that the models fit it the best at the moment. It most certainly isn’t the correct model, their too much discrepancy in the calculated and apparent DE by a huge order or magintude. But it’s the best model at the moment.
It’s not tired light folks, sorry 🙃
There’s very little serious debate outside of niche interner forums populated by non-physicistsv weirdly enough.
i like that as well
Depends on your definition. It seems Neptune-type planets are either included, or not included, varying from speaker to speaker. They’re mostly volatiles, as opposed to what we’d call “rock”, and do have H/He right at the surface. But, it’s largely ammonia and water underneath, instead.
Matter in the universe is 98% hydrogen and helium (as of the current billion years, anyway). Any strong enough gravitational field is going to end up pulling in a lot of it. Smaller fields like ours tend to have trouble holding on to it, because it doesn’t take much solar wind to blow it off. So, yes, any Jupiter-sized gas planet should have that composition. Although, there’s at least one known example of a former, or maybe potential, gas giant, that’s been stripped down to it’s core.
Public service announcement that when you vent helium into Earth’s atmosphere, it blows off into space forever, and we’ve used up a lot of the stuff already.
Depends on your definition. It seems Neptune-type planets are either included, or not included, varying from speaker to speaker.
I’ve also heard them referred to as “ice giants”. Are they a subcategory of gas giants, or separate category?
Neither gas giant nor ice giant are defined terms in astronomy, so *shrug*
Uranus is made of methane.
Got a couple of anti-science dorks here.

Well this is really interesting! Why is Uranus mostly water ammonia and methane and not hydrogen and helium?
You should scroll down.

Mostly, just because almost all matter in the universe is those two elements. However not always true. Uranus does have a very thick hydrogen and helium mixture in its atmosphere (80%/15%), but it also has a solid core, and technically by mass is mostly water, ammonia, and methane in a supercritical ice phase.
It’s bonkers how the universe is almost entirely H and He and yet, here we are.

Poetically it’s been said that we are stardust, or star stuff. More grounded, we’re the extremely minor byproducts of a star’s explosion.
Carl Sagan famously said that from his 1980 television series “Cosmos”:
“The Cosmos is within us. We are made of star-stuff. We are a way for the Universe to know itself.”
What I didn’t realize at the time was, he probably made up that word to avoid using the word “stardust” that Joni Mitchell used in her song at Woodstock, which certainly had some influence on him.
Joni Mitchell wasn’t at Woodstock. The song was named Woodstock.
If we want to get kind of nitpicky, water, ammonia, and methane are also mostly hydrogen
No, by mass, they’re certainly not.
If we really get nitpicky, all the atoms in all of the elements are mostly made of empty space, aka nothing.
If we want to
keep the thread goingget even more nitpicky, empty space doesn’t exist, exactly. There’s just one big quantum field filling the universe.Although, future physics may change that picture.
The whole universe is mostly nothing, just like the stars and planets too.











