in different social networks I often see a table of fediverse alternatives to centralized social networks like twitter = mastodon and so on, but I noticed that the alternative to reddit is piefed and not lemmy, can someone explain what kind of fediverse project this is, and is it different from lemmy?🤔
From a user perspective, they’re not much different. Both share the same technology and the same content, talking to each other freely. You can view Lemmy content on PieFed and vice versa. Collectively, they’re all (together with Kbin/Mbin) called the Threadiverse.
PieFed experience is more curated, both on user level and globally. It allows you to quickly customize your feed, but it also makes some big global decisions for you - like blocking right-wing media on purely ideological grounds, on a software level (i.e. on all instances, aka servers). PieFed also has a few nice-to-have features Lemmy doesn’t.
Lemmy is more of a wild west, a raw and less curated experience. All moderation here is instance-based, and you can do anything you want as long as it agrees with the instance rules. There are less cool features here, but also more freedom and decentralization.
Overall, there’s no harm trying both and seeing what you like best.
ActivityPub is the fediverse protocol, lemmy and piefed are software implementations of that protocol.
In a similar way, email is a protocol, and Gmail and Exchange/Outlook are software implementations of that protocol. You can use Gmail to send email to Outlook users. Different people can administer their own Exchange servers on their own domains.
And some features of the software work best with other people who use the same version of the same software, although most things kinda work between different software. Like how calendar invites sometimes act weird between users of different software, but for the most part the core functions work OK.
So lemmy and piefed (and mbin and sublinks and some others) are different software trying to speak to other fediverse services through the ActivityPub protocol. It mostly works, but some of the details don’t work exactly the same between each type of software.
I would complete ignore whatever politics of Lemmy or PieFed people try and sway you with. Way too many people on here trying to start drama.
In my experience, Lemmy moves slow but things are very stable. PieFed moves fast adding lots of features that Lemmy is missing, but tends to break things a little more. Both are very useable platforms.
I’ve personally had great interactions with the Lemmy and PieFed devs, and I know they collaborate with each other behind the scenes.
And if you’re unsure, I would just make a PieFed and lemmy account and try both. But the specific PieFed or Lemmy instance you choose might matter just as much as which software you choose.
Yep. Thats what ive seen on both my instances. Piefed has had a lot of new features. Lemmy has had stable dev work.
What kind of features?
Is it mostly mod stuff or is it changing how/what you (can) post?
Some additional features that PieFed has:
- You can create posts with polls.
- Crossposts will display comments from everywhere that something is crossposted to (organized into their own sections)
- Feeds for combining multiple communities into one.
- Mods can move posts from one community to another (such as in cases where a post is a better fit for a different community)
- You can blur images with spoiler tags instead of needing to use NSFW.
- You can tag posts and then filter down posts based on those tags within a community.
- You can set a time/date for when something gets posted.
A more complete list can be found here: https://join.piefed.social/features/
Lemmy is the alternative to reddit but some people really dislike communists so they
vibe-coded(apparently a human wrote all of it, I thought otherwise based on some coding patterns.) their own platform called piefed. So now we have two. Use whichever you like, though personally I don’t trust piefeds security and that was vindicated just last week when someone asked an LLM to check it’s security and it immediately found a hole the size of jupiter.I’ve tried them both along with a few different lemmy instances and found .today on lemmy is my best fit.
Since others have covered the technical angle, I’ll say I prefer lemmy from a social perspective. My instance doesn’t block other instances, banning users only for extreme cases. I prefer to choose my experience for myself without being ideologically guided by someone else’s values.
For all the criticisms of the lemmy developers, their biases don’t make it into the code. Instances are run according to the admins and user’s wishes, which allows .today to operate as openly as possible. Piefed, on the other hand, suffers from the biases of its developer, who not only blocks users but also instances of admins who don’t align with them. They have passed along their ban list to other admins as well, getting users banned for disagreeing with them. That’s not the behavior of someone I want running my platform of choice.
Along with that. I, personally, don’t like the idea of reputation, low score flags, karma or any system based on the votes of users, since they can be easily manipulated. It feels like Piefed is trying to implement a more intense karma system, which was one of my main problems with reddit. I believe each post and comment should stand on its own merit.
Good point. If there is a karma system, the main activity for a sizeable (and by definition overrepresented) chunk of the user base will just use the platform to maximize karma, whether for nefarious purposes or just because people treat gamified systems like games. Having real user registrations (so you can block individual users) as opposed to a 4chan like thing, but having no karma system or engagement optimization algorithm in the feed, are the requirements for a healthy forum.
I have a hard time donating to the Lemmy developers knowing that money from it goes to run .ml.
If it went to fund a neutral test instance I’d feel much better about it.
FYI only donations via OpenCollective are used for lemmy.ml hosting (see the expenses). Other donation methods are purely to pay for development work.
Piefed is cleaner. Also it’s not made by Stalin’s fanbois.
Lemmy’s devs may be tankies, but doesn’t the piefed software come pre-built with instance blocks that can’t be modified?
Kinda sounds like the choice between a brand-new Ford Pinto and a Toyota Hilux with 800,000 miles on it
what instances are blocked? anyone able to point me where I can see this?








