This was five years in to Gallagher taking over from uncle George Gately, the creator of the strip. At this point he was still doing quite a faithful job imitating the spirit of the original, altho there were perhaps some subtle differences to be seen.
Anyway, in almost all the strips from this period, Orangecat is undeniably front-and-center the focus of attention. He’s the star, he’s the focus, and I don’t think “HC without HC” would have worked for many of those. Except perhaps… this one.
OTOH, there’s a kind of secondary joke going on in that ‘everything exists in Orangecat’s world,’ and he doesn’t even have to acknowledge it to put his stamp on it. Something like that. And bonus pts for HC doing some kind of animal shuffle that is absolutely *not* how cats walk, but IIRC it was indeed Gately who came up with that stride.
Btw, there’s a famous group of foul-mouthed, escaped African Grey parrots at Lincolnshire Wildlife Park in England that arrived spontaneously. Greys are considered the ‘Cadillacs’ of parrots, and a big part of that is because of their intelligence and mimicry skills. So of course, when mixing with other Greys and other parrots, they taught each other various swear words, as well as follow-up laughter. I tried to find a good video, but alas, I guess it’s too hard to hear properly unless you’re there live.
From what I can make it that year should definitely be Gallagher but that signature looks more like Gately.
Anyway, I fixed the comic.

Nice…
Yeah, that’s definitely Gately’s sig at bottom. So unless this is a reprint, which is highly unlikely to me since G was an active cartoonist at the time, this is a very common case of a successor cartoonist preserving their predecessor’s sig for some years afterwards. And of course, Gately had passed 2yrs earlier.
It is confusing. I’ll ask around


