Title is pretty explicit, what do you think about separating church (or religion as a whole) from the state?
Agree with others that its a good ideal to strive for, but most bourgeios democracies, even though they claim “secularism”, they rarely practice it.
Take the US for example, that has openly proclaimed a “crusade” against Islam since Bush the younger, and oppresses Muslims internally and bombs them abroad. Or the influence of Christian fundamentalists on policy like abortion, treatment of women and LGBTQ communities, etc. Or France and its treatment of Muslims.
The leaders and populace of these countries are unavoidably members of certain religions, and that influences their actions regardless of whatever laws are on the books, and they will find ways to put their religious beliefs into practice. I’d almost prefer a country with a single dominant religion just be open and honest about its influence on their state and rule, rather than dishonestly claim secularism without practicing it.
Ideally it should be no different than language recognition; just recognize the major religions of your country like you would a language like the PRC does.
Pointless.
Religion should be squashed period.
Gullible beliefs should be allowed only in atomized form.
How to not gain any support 101
Context takes precedence. No universal principle that always applies. The IRGC is an example of why. They may not be communist, but they are undeniable making a difference against imperialism. An example from the other end is the US. Though it has a lot of Christian influence going on, it does technically separate church and state, and enforce a certain amount of “freedom of religious practice.” Meanwhile, it is one of the most murderous entities in history.
But just as it would be foolish to take these examples and say “see, religion is super important for liberation obviously, while atheistic imperialism destroys the world”, it would also be foolish to look at the atheistic nature of China or the USSR and say “see, atheism is the only thing that provides any value toward liberation”, then look at the Jewish relationship to israel and zionism and say “see, religion only ever destroys and genocides.”
Separation of church and state can have its benefits. However, it’s neither a magic fix to problems of religion, nor is religion necessarily a problem intrinsically. To universalize it would be to say that a communal indigenous people practicing a religion based on stewardship of the environment and helping one another is inherently awful, the same as zionists using religion to justify genocide. This makes no sense. We have to struggle against the problems of religion that are immediately real—problems which intersect with other sources of systemic abuse—without slipping into a view that singling out religion will be the pet issue that resolves most problems.
I like this analysis of things, as it steps away from idealism and opts for a materialist and grounded paradigm!
Separating church from state is only a necessity so long as either institution exists, and for most cultures throughout history up until relatively recently neither institution did.
As such it’s an issue for socialism that will be resolved with the development of the communist society.
Religion was the government since time immemorial.
you’re right i totally forgot about that time priests of Ukko called for a crusade my b
As a Muslim, It’s best to have religion separated from state because of how much the bourgeois has turned religious sanctions against the proletariat.
Most religions are ahead of their times for aligning with Socialism to a degree, but unfortunately religious institutions are the ones bribed into cherry picking for the bourgeois. Pretty much what Marx noticed about his country’s churches always being pro war for the bourgeoisie’s agenda and yet abandoned everything Jesus said about feeding the poor and hungry.
As a fellow muslim, i am pretty sure you experienced the whole “oh you are a socialist/communist it means you are an atheist”, religious institutions are continually used by the bourgeoisie to spread disinformation amongst the masses.
Mostly with mega churches since I am a converted Muslim. But I do see that in certain Muslim countries such as UAE. Which is ironic for UAE, cause Islam is against working with Epstein and enslaving fellow Muslims.
Oh wow that’s so intresting, mashallah tha’s really a pleasure to see, and yeah mega churches sound like hell lmfao, not just in the UAE but that is the epicenter currently but some Muslim scholars allow themselves to be used to legitimize imperialism and capitalism through their calling of left wing thought as heresy.
can someone more knowledgeable explain the relevant history of communism in west asia? i can’t remember where i heard it but someone said the soviet insistence on atheism was partly responsible for the failure of communism in the region. is there any truth in that?
I don’t think it’s possible to have genuine separation of church and state without state atheism, not just “secularism.” The problem is that if religious people can run for office they will just make up “secular” reasons for their legislation. It tends to be so silly that most of the time they don’t even hide it: they will outright argue to the public that they’re implementing the law for religious reasons, but will just write down a non-religious one for the record.
Take same-sex marriage in the US for example, where US politicians started to float some argument that the definition of marriage is between a man and a woman therefore if you allow it you’re abusing the definition of words. Like… c’mon, not a single soul on earth finds that argument actually convincing. It’s just a silly argument made up to justify a religious-motivated law.
You cannot have scientific management of the economy ran by people who believe in magic. Sorry.
You mean making anything state-related atheistic but maintaining the freedom to believe in a religion for the general person?
State atheism isn’t “it’s illegal to be a theist,” it means that the state is explicitly atheistic in its law, not just secular (indifferent to theism/atheism), but that people in government, or at least anyone in a very high position of power, actually have to be atheists. You can still be free to believe whatever you want, but just don’t run for public office if you are detached from reality. Countries like this often have historically even provided funding and support for things like religious institutions like churches for people to freely worship, but since it is done by atheists, the motives are slightly different: it is there to help contain the religiosity, not to spread it, so things like evangelism in banned. If you come to religion on your own free will without indoctrination or evangelism, then there still is a place for you, but neither that place or yourself can then use that as a basis to evangelize.
I like my religion so my opinion may be biased. personally I think it’s the worst idea ever. because of this idea, my country is filled with criminals and greedy bourgeoisie. if my country doesn’t do it, then my country might already be a non-marxist socialist country.
“Non-Marxist socialist” makes literally zero sense.
Please don’t tell me you’re from France, that would make your comment even more hilarious.
“Non-Marxist socialist” makes literally zero sense.
how could that be? isn’t socialism about turning ownership of the means of production into cooperative/public property?
Please don’t tell me you’re from France, that would make your comment even more hilarious.
why do you think I’m from France?
And what politcal theory or ideology is this magical non-Marxist socialism based on? What writers, politicans, or theorists guide your vision of “”“socialism”“”?
Also you come across as a typical religious fundamentalist. “If only everyone believed in my religion then everything would be perfect! Only my people know the true word of god!”
“Society is decrepit and falling apart because our people stray from the word of god!”
It should be separated completely, and the state should actively fight against any religious oppression. IMO state should also work to educate people out of belief. Not like, forcefully, but educational material/guidelines should promote science and critical thinking, some of the best killers of religion. It will take several generations, but I think there would a critical point where the numbers would fall drastically.
The end goal would be to build a society in which the need of religion is gone. The vast majority of current religions have no place in a modern society. Almost all of them have some teachings that directly oppose the kind of society we want to create. Some religions try to have sects that change and “modernize” but at that point, just admit your religions is just some imaginary bullshit you can change as you feel needs. You can’t have a holy book of rules defined by God, and then decide that those rules need to change cause your God was wrong. Any positive aspects of religion are just generally accepted as good things to do for a society. Helping the helpless, feeding the hungry, don’t murder, etc etc. We don’t need religion to promote those. Those things are just part of what the state SHOULD promote itself. The harm comes from when the same book that says “feed poor people” also says girls that are raped have to marry their rapist, or homosexuals should be stoned to death, etc. We as a sentient species are capable of just saying “we should do this, and we shouldn’t do that, and we don’t need some magic sky daddy to tell us that.”
Pretty solid move tbh












