- cross-posted to:
- progressivepolitics@lemmy.world
- worldnews@lemmy.ml
- cross-posted to:
- progressivepolitics@lemmy.world
- worldnews@lemmy.ml
When Torture Allegations Threaten a Heroic Narrative: The Uncomfortable Questions Azov Must Answer
[The author of this article is a Ukrainian historian and Research Scholar at the Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Clark University]
“Don’t Discredit Azov”
On November 2, social media erupted over a photograph of a 14-year-old boy being escorted out of a house at 7-A Soniachna Street in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka, just outside Kyiv. The house turned out to be a secret facility for newly mobilized recruits and deserters from the Ukrainian military. As later emerged, 26 servicemen had been held there, at least four of whom bore unmistakable signs of having been beaten.
The First Azov Corps of Ukraine’s National Guard confirmed that the property belonged to the unit. Almost immediately, the Corps commander, Denys Prokopenko, known by his call sign “Redis,” released a video addressing the events in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka. His outrage, however, was directed not at the apparent abuse of the men held at the facility, but at those drawing attention to it.
People who, he claimed, had “nothing whatsoever to do with defending the country” and “do nothing to support the defense forces” were instead “engaging in sabotage behind the lines,” “discrediting Ukrainian servicemen,” and “creating an image that serves Russia’s interests.” He urged the public not to “play into the enemy’s hands,” not to “stage provocations,” not to “discredit the Azov unit,” and not to “sully the honor of the Ukrainian military.”
But one might reasonably ask: What could possibly do more to discredit Azov than the discovery of beaten men being held inside one of its secret facilities?
The questions practically ask themselves. Who beat these men, and why? Why were they being kept in a private house rather than treated in a hospital? Why were they guarded like criminals? Under what conditions were they detained? How long had they been held there? Were they subjected to ill-treatment, degrading treatment, or torture?
And perhaps the most troubling question of all: What, exactly, was Azov doing running such a facility in the first place?
Valentyna: Rescuer or “Provocateur”?
On the morning of November 2, an ambulance pulled up outside the house on Soniachna Street in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka. Out stepped Valentyna Moloda, 49, dressed in a red paramedic uniform. She had come to enter the building and determine whether Ukrainian servicemen were being held inside who, according to information she had received, were in urgent need of medical attention.
She was accompanied by Serhii Radzytskyi, a 31-year-old war veteran who introduced himself as the ambulance driver.
The two called the police, asking officers to investigate reports that men were being unlawfully detained inside the house, as the law required. The police arrived. They subsequently issued an official statement declaring that reports of the “alleged unlawful detention of people” were “untrue.”
Yet the officers refused to let Valentyna enter the building to verify their assurances.
For hours, Valentyna negotiated with the police, while documenting her efforts on social media. Word spread. More than a hundred people gathered outside the property. Tensions escalated into confrontations with the police. Eggs were thrown at officers. Protesters tried to force open the gates and break into the compound.
Among them was Oleksii, a 14-year-old boy who climbed onto the gate, shouted at the soldiers inside and hurled stones toward the building. He was then struck with a shovel, causing him to fall into the compound. Once inside, he says, he was beaten with “a shovel, feet and fists.” The boy also alleges that his clothes, including his underwear, were cut open, leaving him standing “almost naked.”
As the standoff dragged on, Valentyna grew desperate. She dropped to her knees before the police officers, pleading to be allowed inside to reach the injured men whom she believed were being held there in serious condition. The photograph of a woman in a paramedic uniform kneeling before armed police officers swept across the Ukrainian internet, provoking an outpouring of anger and disbelief.
After several hours of confrontation, Valentyna was finally allowed to leave the building, taking four visibly injured men with her. Most had bruising around their eyes, consistent with possible beatings.
Oleksandr Pivnenko, the commander of Ukraine’s National Guard, who had arrived at the scene, offered no explanation for why all four men bore signs of injury — or whether they had received proper medical care while being held inside the house.
Saving Private Andrii
Among the four men was Andrii Kuleshov, 36. He was the reason Valentyna had come to the house in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka in the first place. She was acting at the request of his relative, Tetiana Kirieieva.
On August 20, Andrii was forcibly mobilized in Kyiv. The following day, he fled his military unit before even reaching a training camp. Soon afterward, he underwent major surgery. He had an abdominal stoma.
In plain English, he had a surgically created opening in his abdomen.
On September 24, Azov soldiers apprehended him. They allegedly broke his leg.
Then they took him to the house in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka.
Under guard. Into a basement. With a stoma in his abdomen. There, according to his family’s account, he was beaten.
And held for 37 days.
Tetiana, aware of Andrii’s medical condition and the circumstances of his detention, fought to have him hospitalized. She hoped that once he was admitted, he could undergo a proper military medical evaluation—one that would determine his fitness for service based on his actual health, rather than the military’s apparent determination to keep him in uniform.
But they repeatedly denied permission to take him to a hospital.
Meanwhile, according to Tetiana, Azov personnel were demanding money from Andrii’s family. They told her to pay a 100,000-hryvnia ($2,400) “fine” for his unauthorized absence from military service — a penalty with no legal basis.
Tetiana contacted a lawyer, who submitted formal inquiries to Ukraine’s State Bureau of Investigation and the military prosecutor’s office. Yet, according to the family’s account, after the lawyers visited Andrii, a serviceman came to him in the middle of the night and beat him again.
Still, no answer came.
On October 30, Tetiana turned to Valentyna Moloda for help. Valentyna promised to get Andrii out.
Moloda is a physician specializing in cosmetic medicine, with a background in surgery. She spent years working at a plastic surgery clinic and now runs her own private practice, Moloda-Ya, which specializes in “gerontology, aesthetics, plastic, and reconstructive surgery.”
According to investigators, Moloda had been offering what she called “emergency evacuations” from military recruitment centers and military units using an ambulance. Such operations have become one way in Ukraine to extract men who have been forcibly mobilized.
Investigators allege that Moloda charged 107,000 hryvnias (approximately $2,600) for her services. They also claim she purchased an ambulance just days before the incident specifically to retrieve Andrii.
Ukrainian authorities arrested and jailed both Tetiana and Valentyna on charges of obstructing the “lawful activities of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.” Both were ordered held for two months without the possibility of bail.
Andrii, meanwhile, was finally hospitalized. He is now receiving the medical care he needed.
The two women who fought to get him that care are behind bars.
Azov’s Torture Chamber Is Not an Isolated Case: The “Pit” System in Ukraine’s Military
To date, no one in Azov’s leadership has explained why Andrii, a man with an abdominal stoma, was held under guard at the Soniachna Street facility for 37 days. What conceivable military value could a man in his condition have had?
Nor has anyone publicly addressed the allegations made by Tetiana and her lawyer: that Andrii was brutally beaten inside the building, confined to a basement in unsanitary conditions despite having post-surgical wounds requiring specialized medical care, and that his relatives were pressured to pay a bribe to secure his hospitalization.
Azov’s leadership has also avoided explaining why the other three men hospitalized on November 2 bore apparent signs of beatings. Who inflicted those injuries? And how did they sustain them while serving under Azov’s command — and no one else’s?
What we do know comes from Pavlo Kurchenko, call sign “Kil,” the commander of Military Unit 3121 of the National Guard’s First Azov Corps, which oversaw the Soniachna Street facility.
According to Kurchenko, one of the men, Oleksandr Perminov, was placed there because he intended to go absent without leave and encouraged others to do the same. Another, Ivan Yareshko, was allegedly heavily intoxicated by drugs and behaving aggressively toward fellow servicemen. A third, Oleksandr Pavliuchenko, was said to have abused alcohol.
In other words, all four men, including Andrii, were considered “problem soldiers.” And problem soldiers, apparently, required “corrective measures.” This is where the story of one house outside Kyiv begins to look like something much larger.
For years, accounts from within Ukraine’s military have described a system of extrajudicial punishment known as yamy — literally, “pits.” Sometimes these are actual holes dug into the ground. Sometimes they are cages. Sometimes they are isolated rooms or buildings, like the one on Soniachna Street.
What they have in common is their alleged purpose: to punish soldiers whom commanders consider troublesome, insubordinate, or unwilling to obey orders — including orders to participate in assault operations — as well as those accused of desertion or going absent without leave.
According to accounts of the practice, soldiers confined in these makeshift detention sites are subjected to psychological and physical abuse, including treatment that may amount to torture. They may be deprived of adequate food, water, sleep and medical attention. Severe beatings are allegedly used as a means of “reeducation” — and as a warning to anyone else contemplating defiance.
A recent journalistic investigation into the Ukrainian military unit known as Skelia exposed allegations of similar practices, including physical abuse and degrading conditions of confinement. But accounts from multiple sources suggest that these “pits” are not merely the aberrations of one rogue commander or one particularly brutal unit. They point to a potentially systemic practice within a military struggling with low morale, unwilling recruits, and widespread unauthorized absences.
Against that backdrop, the discovery on Soniachna Street raises a disturbing possibility.
What if the building was not an isolated detention site, but part of the same informal punishment system?
What if Azov, too, maintained its own “pit” — a place where soldiers deemed troublesome were sent to be “reeducated”? And what if the beatings and alleged mistreatment were not failures of discipline, but the very instruments through which discipline was enforced?
If so, the scandal is not simply that men were beaten inside an Azov-controlled facility. It is that the facility may have existed precisely to make such treatment possible.
The Reputation Worth Saving — and the Men Who Aren’t
For years, human rights organizations documented credible allegations of torture and other serious abuses involving Azov fighters. The U.S. Congress restricted military assistance to Azov over its extremist origins. In 2024, Washington lifted the restrictions. Azov, the Zelensky government, and their Western allies had spent years painstakingly rehabilitating the unit’s image, transforming a once-notorious formation into the celebrated elite of Ukraine’s military.
Then came the house in Petropavlivska Borshchahivka.
And suddenly, the old questions were back.
No wonder Azov’s leadership rushed to defend its reputation instead of answering them. The accusations were familiar: sabotage, provocations, Russian propaganda, discrediting the military. But torture does not become Russian disinformation simply because its alleged perpetrators wear Ukrainian uniforms.
Nor is Azov necessarily an exception. Accounts of punitive “pits,” beatings, degrading treatment and denial of medical care suggest a wider system of extrajudicial punishment within Ukraine’s armed forces — one that deserves far more scrutiny than it has received.
Western governments, meanwhile, have shown little appetite for confronting such allegations. They have invested too much political and moral capital in Ukraine’s military to welcome evidence that complicates its heroic image. But a just war does not justify torture. And human rights mean nothing if they apply only to one’s enemies.
For years, Azov has fought to convince the world that it is no longer what its critics once accused it of being. Now it has a more urgent task: explaining why men allegedly emerged beaten from a facility under its control.
You cannot whitewash a torture allegation by calling the people who expose it traitors. And you cannot defend Azov’s honor by refusing to investigate what Azov may have done.
There are literally hundreds of videos showing how people snatchers brutally beat people they kidnap (and anyone trying to stop them, including women), there are videos of “recruits” being handcuffed for transport to their military units, to be honest I don’t understand why is anyone surprised to learn deserters are being abused. Like what did you think happens to those people after they were brutally kidnapped and hauled to the army like criminals?
Its actually good because the Ukrainian water torture simply washes out the evil Ruzzian mind virus from their frontal lobe and turns them into humble unterschmensh for the next racial war against the illiberal and scary Asiatic hordes to the east!!!




