for context: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2026/oct/22/finland-google-felling-trees-datacentre
“‘Pure arrogance’: anger in Finland as Google illegally fells 250,000 trees for datacentre”
death sentence for big wigs. its the only way.
Really there is no deterant for capital. Change it to jail time you pay someone to break the law for you.
Abolish the corporate veil. If it’s worth doing, then they can afford liability insurance. They only care about money.
I say let them build it, then on the opening day show up with a wrecking ball crew and dismantle it no warning or chance to recover material.
Normally I would say sue them the cost of restoration + damages but google is notorious for just not paying files or restitutions.
That or sue them and then when they ignore it cancel all facilities for google there.
Military training exercise. Just bomb the fucking thing into a crater.
Charge them for the munitions.
That all sounds excellent for their environment 👍
Nothing a guillotine can’t fix
A fine is only acceptable if it’s a fine on top of the cost of restoring this forest to it’s previous state.
And not getting to build the data center
Unless the forest already had a data centre in it. I think that’s part of returning it to it’s previous state
In a way it does
Maybe if we additionally bound offences to lobby permits?
Additionally to counting x-million $ offences as jailtime-worthy i mean
Story may be true but that image is AI.
Story also claims that they took the topsoil away, but the flyover in the Guardian article shows soil windrows. They look like topsoil admixed with subsoil, and randomly scattered in some cases. Not super great soil management.
sure that’s AI? would the Guardian use it if it was?
That photo isn’t in the Guardian’s post.
How do we know that is an AI image?
I ran it though and AI image detector - zerogpt. They can scan for invisible water marks that AI places on images.
Yeah but for that’d they’d have to have access to some pretty damn valuable trade secrets, so its plausible the website is lying
Honestly, that’s how I was told that they work, and looked into it with a reasonable degree of due diligence. I’m not technically strong on computer stuff but from what I read that’s how it works.
I don’t get Lemmy’s AI stance in general - half the folks want AI called out and bust out the pitchforks at the slightest hint of it, and others like you call AI detection shit, which is also fair.
Instead of being a drooling AI policeman behind a keyboard, typing out ‘SLOP!!!’ next to a jarred Rainbow Dash figure, however, I added some context about the article in my original comment.
I don’t know what you guys want anymore lol
Thats valid, and I feel like it’s easy to expect everyone here to be fairly read up on the topic, when really only a vocal minority actually exists lol.
I’m no AI researcher, but I’ll admit AI is cool on a mathematical level so I’ve read a lot. If you’re interested, I can kinda try to describe how I’m anti AI, and AI detector.
One of the somewhat recent AI breakthroughs is the scalability of generative adversial models. All that being fancy talk for we like 2 robots arguing against each other, because it works well on a calculator but also on a supercomputer.
That scalability caused all the hype and stuff, but importantly (at least image models) are 2 models trained using super computers to detect/fool each other. This means that, to make a detector, any small company would need half that equation - but it would have to be slightly better than the LLM companies supercomputers. And even then it’d be just to detect a signal slightly more often than noise (so real expensive to probably not even work).
Even more recently, this ‘unable to detect without a supercomputer’ became dangerous for regurgitating training data, poisoning models with themselves, so a lot of watermarking techniques were developed.
Unfortunately the companies making these watermarks aren’t idiots. They do it similarly to cryptographically signing a document, but hide a signal within the data, and keep the key to themselves.
Without that key, any detector is essentially trying to rebuild encrypted data that they don’t even know where is, which is to say entirely useless.
Ugh, so the detectors are just AI as well? And you can’t even check accurately without a super computer?
I should just throw in the fucking towel with even trying to sleuth it out. I post a lot. A lot a lot. Because of the volume some of my posts end up getting flagged as AI. I wasn’t able to check really until about a month ago and now you’re saying it doesn’t even work to begin with.
Can I get permission to kick the next person that posts the stupid slop cat in their gonads? Im tired boss…
Make them pay the fines in voting shares.
They should be made to replant the whole area with trees, along with a suitable monetary fine.
a suitable monetary fine is more than the value of the forest to society, the point of fines in capitalism is to internalize negative externalities.
There’s a follow up on this from 29 Oct 2026 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/29/finland-criminal-investigation-google-clearing-forest-datacentre
Unless I missed something it basically just boiled down to “we’re looking in to it”. Nothing about forcing a stop, fines, anything.
Well, let’s start by fining them per tree.
Should be pay the fine and reverse all the damage you done. And still dont have a permit to build.
Trees are hard to count to an exact number, but we know the total area of land. A million euros per hectare sounds like a reasonable starting point for illegal clear cutting by a large foreign company. That only makes 330 million in this instance, sure, but it’s at least an order of magnitude more than the timber itself + the land itself it sits on is worth. A hectare is not a lot of land, 330 is a bit more, but Finland has over 20 million hectares of forest.
If they deforested all of Finland in a similar manner, that would then cost them 20 trillion, which they could never afford. Additionally, Finland’s annual budget is under 100 billion euros. For 20 trillion they could reforest the entire country and have 19.something trillion left over for vengeance and/or betterment of their own country.
Trees are hard to count to an exact number, but we know the total area of land.
Easy to estimate, though. Look at the neighboring patches of forest that weren’t destroyed, count how many trees per hectare are in those patches, then multiply by the number of hectares Google cleared. Then multiply by the fine per tree.
How much would it cost to replace a mature evergreen tree? Probably in the range of $25-50K? So let’s say $50K per tree.
Honestly, ecocide really needs to start coming with a prison sentence
One billion € per tree is a good round number.
Maybe you need to learn about fines in Finland…
Corporate employee embezzled €50,000 from company accounts.
Annual net income: €90,000.
Legal Reasoning:
Court assigned 50 day-fines due to seriousness and breach of trust.
Daily fine: €250/day.
Total fine: 50 × €250 = €12,500.
Uh. This makes me think it’ll be cheap for Google: this person profited even after being caught and found guilty
You left out a bit there:
Fine lower than total embezzled sum, combined with civil liability for restitution.
It wasn’t clear to me what that meant. Does it mean the fine was added on top of repaying the 50k? If so then, yes, I did misunderstand
It’s pretty clear that the dude have to give the embezzled money back AND pay the fine. Otherwise the crime would pay.
I didn’t find it clear at first glance so thanks. In the US this type of crime often does pay and that’s my frame of reference
Google’s annual revenue was 400 billion for 2025 so a daily fine in that system SHOULD be just over a billion a day.
revenue and income are not the same, but it would still be hundreds of millions
That’d be nice to see
The problem with this is that it presumes that rich people are rich because of high income. Sure this might hit some lawyer or CEO with a high salary pretty hard at some point, but the owner class couldn’t care less. What is Elon Musk’s income? He doesn’t just get a paycheck like we plebs do. He has assets that appreciate in value that he can borrow against. If he gets a speeding ticket in Finland, how are they going to determine his income? Most of it isn’t even generated in the country. Sure they can maybe come up with some number based on some symbolic CEO salary he pays himself, but that number is ultimately meaningless compared to his actual wealth. So if Elon Musk wanted to, he could speed right through Helsinki and give the Finish people the middle finger.
But that action made him poorer than he would have been, and billionaires are infanous for being stingy.
This will drasticaly reduce how often that happens, so long as there is no profit from it.
the €13bn budget includes the fine, probably.
I wish we had that in Sweden
We do?
Not an income-based one
Sweden has a day-fine system. So your wish is granted. I’m not a genie or anything. Actually both countries have had it for about 100 years.
Doubtful it will be applied in a case against a company though.
The Finnish fine system is the only truly democratic form of financial penalty: the rich and the poor fear a fine alike. And it’s completely obvious and logical on its face - something only the no-nonsense Finns could have come up with.
I wish the entire world adopted it.












