How the fuck didn’t they predict this, genuinely
Probably asked ai and it gave a madeup nonsense response that was treated as fact.
Google will simply start injecting ads directly into the AI result
It doesn’t matter. If mega corporations were at all worried about losing money, we wouldn’t be seeing all this AI push and investment.
They are interested in something more than just more money, of which they already have near limitless reserves. They’re hoping to replace all human workers with AI, and at a later point robots.
What’s the reason why any of us have rights, why governments sometimes listen to us, and why oligarchs have to occassionally pretend like the same laws apply to them as to us?
Because we’re workers, and they all need us. Without workers, their companies, fortunes, status are all worthless. Unless they could automate it all, and remove the need for human workers entirely.
This, to them, is worth infinitely more than a couple billions, or even trillions, of dollars.
The weird thing is once all the workers are gone that means they have no job which means no income which means no money spend… what happens then?
Then you can reduce the global population to a few million and solve global warming.
That’s the part that always confuses me as capitalists what is the end game when you eliminate workers? Cause you also ultimately eliminate consumers and ultimately profits
they literally do not care. as long as it doesn’t happen next quarter
The workers are already dying off, we’re not reproducing at a high enough rate and never will again (only developing countries have high birth rates, partly because they need to have kids to take care of them in old age). Only around 2 workers for 1 pensioner in some western countries nowadays! Used to be double digits.
This is a problem for the retirement class who owns everything even more than it is for the billionaire class that has more power, but actually owns less because they’re less numerous - turns out you need a LOT of resources to keep untold amounts of old people happy and healthy.
It also turns out, that there are two main ways retirement systems work: The ones where you invest for your own future (systems like 401ks for Americans) and the ones where you, the worker, pay for old people to retire, and in turn, others will pay for you to retire later. The former causes a ton of inequality: In the US, people over 55 own 73% of all wealth, baby boomers alone own over 50% - and even among old people there is still a lot of inequality, only like 20% are millionaires. It thus means that for old people to have the best possible retirement, young people need to be paid as little as possible. For the second type of system, this is not an issue, but the issue is that to keep the pension growing with inflation, the ratio of workers to retirees shouldn’t fall. If it does, taxes need to go up. There are some who will say “just print more money”, but apparently you can’t eat money, nor live in it. Things need to be made that you can buy for this money. Even communism can’t save you from there being no workers to produce anything, if there are people who need those things but are too old to work.
So either way, for old people to get to enjoy life without working, there need to be either more workers, or the workers need to be abused more. What if there was a third way? There is! The third way is for productivity per worker to go up. But if you’re demand constrained, more productivity per worker means fewer workers.
Of course, under capitalism, that’s going to suck for the workers who lose their jobs. But eventually there should be degrowth that happens naturally.
If, on the other hand, you lived in a system where everyone gets access to exactly the same resources whether they have a job or not, that is no longer a problem and the reduction in jobs should be seen as a positive.

It’s not even giving answers, it’s more like giving you nagging opinions on what it thinks you’re searching for. That’s even worse.
Wouldn’t it be nice if Google failed? Everything they do is awful. Just a bit shitty company making shit decisions and causing frustration.
Insane that a marketing company has so much influence in the software industry.
If only. Someone. Could have.
Known.
🤌
Guys, if I cut off my balls, will I have cut off my balls?
Or will they like, still be attached to me?
Also, yes, I am a surgeon! Thank you for asking!

Google spent years perfecting the art of making people click links, then built an AI that tells them not to bother. Now advertisers are questioning why they should pay for clicks that never happen. It’s a remarkable business strategy: disrupt your own cash cow before anyone else gets the chance.
Same on Twitter
XTwitter has very different problems: marketers hate politics.
Extra T? Xitter is perfect because “X” is pronounced “sh” in some languages.
I don’t follow
Can you really call this backfiring? Like how was it supposed to work exactly?
I think the plan was to keep users inside Google while somehow preserving the ad machine that depends on sending them elsewhere: AI answers were supposed to stop people leaving for ChatGPT, not stop them clicking ads.
@eicker @ch00f
This is why I think we’ll soon cross a threshold where advertisements start being injected into chat and agent responses.
> Me: check my comms and t3 code then email my weekly update.
> Chatgpt: sure, I’ll get that done. Btw, there’s an Applebee’s a few miles from you. How about heading there for lunch?
> Me: wtf?It can easily be done without making it so intrusive.
Any time you google something and get that AI summary, it uses and displays sources. If you google for products, the sources are usually shops selling those products.
All they have to do is bias the chat interface’s search tool towards customers paying for better placement… If they haven’t already. And then charge their customers for clicks from the chat links.
ChatGPT already does this though it’s unobtrusive for now, and not on every prompt.
That’s already happening: unfortunately, the ROI is well below that of traditional search adverts. 💥
Probably because you could reply to “Btw, there’s an Applebee’s a few miles from you. How about heading there for lunch?” With, “Nah, feel more like fast food right now.” And the bot would happily then suggest McDonald’s and Wendy’s, leaving Applebee’s big mad at paying for ads that ended up recommending competitors.
You do realize you’re talking to a bot, right?
At that point they’d have to agree to pay for preference / referral over specific ad views. Which they might do. And then AI gets way more spammy…
I did stop using their search engine, since it’s completely ruined and useless. Myriad of reasons, some Google self inflicted. They never got ad rev from me since I block ads anyways but it logically follows that people who don’t block ads are turning to LLM and not giving Google ad rev either.
It’s not just ads but the order in which results are placed, or even being in the results at all. It’s been terrible for a decade even without ads.
I searched for Qobuz on Google Play, and the first result was an ad for an AI music generation tool. More or less the complete opposite of what I was looking for. Google sucks, and they need to lose.
Do you use adblocking or privacy DNS?
Usually people are getting those suggestions that insults your intelligence in order to make you disable adblocking and get “good” recommendations.
Same with YT… If you use open source apps without ads or even YT without signing in you get AI junk and useless recommendations.
Once you sign and give data, watching same stuff as before, you’ll get less garbage.
G is not stupid, don’t underestimate their strategy! More you see recommended (for you) “garbage” subconsciously it makes you feel as garbage.
Oh yeah, SEO page ranking crap for many years. Made research especially useless outside of Google Scholar. I think today crawlers get blocked by everyone legitimate aggressively blocking scraper bots too. Reddit stopped letting Google crawl recently too I think?
Like, really – putting their AI summary front and center actually displaces where the ads used to be, causing people to see fewer ads or maybe none at all.
Also bones small web businesses that rely on ads and organic traffic
Exactly. Google gets to keep the user, serve the answer, and potentially sell the ad, while the small sites that produced the useful information lose the visit and the revenue. It’s a neat trick: turn the open web into an unpaid research department, then wonder why fewer independent sites can afford to exist.
oh darn
What I don’t get is why doesn’t google use the ai summary to incentivize clicking links? E.g. first summarize, leave out extra detail and then claim that this detail can be found at the link destination
I think probably because that also undermines their ad aggregation business.
If you spent a lot of time and money on SEO how irritated would you be if you paid for ads on Google and they linked to somewhere else entirely.
We already see this being a problem on spaces where there’s a big corp on the block. I never get
ads“recommended results” for True Value but I do get them for Home Depot and Lowes.Google spent decades building up all these companies to use SEO to get traffic to their sites. New companies can’t afford ad aggregation services because the few ads they run on their sites don’t get seen anymore.
And big companies were going to be more likely to get the click anyway, but can weather the AI overview storm much easier.
If you spent a lot of time and money on SEO how irritated would you be if you paid for ads on Google and they linked to somewhere else entirely.
Those are kind of opposites: SEO is what you do so you wouldn’t need to pay for ads.
But the idea is that Google would prefer your links to other competitors in the AI summaries. It’s not difficult to do.
I’m absolutely positive that some companies engage in both. That’s why when you search for hardware store near you you get an ad for Home Depot and an actual first result for Home Depot.
I wasn’t conflating the two, but trying to point out that their system is a two part system and AI breaks both parts.













