Almost like oppressive authoritarian regimes suck, whether the guy running the factory is there because he’s buddies with the guy in charge or because of The Will of the Worker’s Party (also he’s buddies with the guy in charge)
In the Soviet Union, factories were run by a trio, called the “Triangle.” There was the manager of the factory, who typically worked their way up from the bottom. There was the party representative, who was there to bring a more all-sided viewpoint that local viewpoints may miss. Finally, there was the trade union representative, who was elected by the rest of the workers at the factory. The trade unions set wage agreements, controlled the wall-newspaper (a form of newsletter for the factory), and were in charge of making sure the needs and interests of the rank and file were met. Unpopular managers were thrown out by the trade unions.
It’s easy to imagine a vignette and believe it to be reality, but when you actually look at historical reality it paints an extremely different picture from what our guts tell us. Our gut feelings have been shaped by the Red Scare, whether we realize it or not.
Is that why trump wants to build a wall? Because he’s a tankie? /s
something something horseshoe
marxism leninism ewwww
council communism is key

What’s the problem with Marxism-Leninism that council communism solves? Soviet democracy is already a form of council-based socialism, and you can have different government structures while still being a Marxist-Leninist.
Soviet democracy, like the ones the bolsheviks overturned and slew before appropriating the label?
Can you explain what you mean by that? How did the Bolsheviks “overturn and slay” the soviets, and how do you think the Soviet Union’s democratic structures functioned? I don’t think you have a very good idea of why the Bolsheviks were able to establish the Soviet Union nor what the democratic structures within looked and functioned like. It looks more like you’re trying to portray the Bolsheviks as some evil force, rather than a popularly supported party that transitioned the soviets into the basis of the new government apparatus.
I don’t see how you expect to convince others of your views if you don’t even have a surface-level understanding of events and structures. If you can’t make a completed point, these petty jabs just make you look ill-informed and sabotages any point you may have legitimately had. Develop your points, provide actual historical context and critique the structures as they actually existed. Otherwise we Marxist-Leninists will continue to develop and front our positions, steadily gaining more and more people to our side.
A tankie will try to tell you that ML is the only valid form of communism.
I’ve had this argument with them before, multiple times. It’s just dogma to them. They’re no better than religious fanatics in their zealotry.
A liberal will defend a genocide if it’s the right political party doing it. I’ve had this argument with them before, multiple times. It’s just dogma to them. They’re no better than religious fanatics in their zealotry.
ML isn’t really a “form of communism,” it’s a toolset to analyze the world and guide how we proceed. The various states controlled by Marxist-Leninist parties all have different structures best suited to their characteristics. It isn’t about “dogma” or “zealotry,” it’s about aligning on a methodical and scientifically correct way of analyzing society, history, and revolutionary struggle. Making up lies about your political adversaries only works if they can’t respond, you know.
I reported this because it’s obviously not archaeology, but oh look it’s a mod that posted it, and archaeology is mispelt in the community name.
That’s all very shady.
McCarthy isn’t sending his best
Archeology is also acceptable but if it bothers you I recommend blocking the community.
why is this here?
OP is mod here so apparently they’re just going to do whatever
because on other com it could be deleted , wouldn’t it? But mostly this com is for all history related stuff
You’re truly standing up to the man here. You tell m son.

Niemand hat die Absicht eine Mauer zu errichten.
The Antifaschistischer Schutzwall was of course to protect the DDR utopia from the evil CIA Nazis in the West. That’s why all those people were shot trying to get in.
Are you denying that the Americans failed at denazification and instead just put the Nazis back in charge because it was too hard?
The denazification was certainly anything but perfect and a lot of old Nazis ended up in positions of power again. Claiming that the Nazis were back in charge is far removed from reality, though. Also, my point was that Ulbricht built the wall to keep their own population from running away. I guess the irony was too subtle here.
I disagree 👍
Imagine moving the goalposts so far they left earths orbit.
Explain how they’ve moved?
Gesundheit
What is the truth you are referring to? I’m probably a tankie according to you, enlighten me, would you please?
It is, that tankies simp two authoritatian regimes, and try to pretend the attrocities committed by those, do not exist, or “were not that bad”, even though millions died. And that they are supporting Russian imperialism and modern CCP capitalism, and still pretend, they are communists. Oh, and they support genocide, if the “right side” is doing it. If you believe workers should own the means of production, you are not a tankie, but if you think something like, trying to erase tibetan culture is ok, you are probably a tankie.
Tell me about the Chinese atrocities, please.
I mean, there is that currently active genocide they’re doing…
These are tough topics. I used to hold very negative views about the CPC, but I also know that I lived in a place that surrounded me with anti-CPC material in all directions. China can do no good because it is built on blood the blood of minorities. Russia can do nothing right and must not resist, because resisting is imperial.
No one can resist the US if they are theocratic and therefore evil. The western world is a bastion of democracy, and anywhere else in the world that doesn’t look exactly like that isn’t a democracy, don’t worry about my party’s list system but do critise the party list system elsewhere. The only entity that can talk about money is the IMF, everything else is a debt trap. Cuba is subjugating their people and authoritarian, just don’t read about them supporting independence movements around the world throughout the country’s existance, especially don’t look at their support for people’s independence from actual aparteid.
The blame for the failure of the soviets should rest on the imperial, colonial, nazi, fascists powers that undermined them and invaded them and not the peasants who didnt want to die as serfs.
It is not black and white, never is. The USA and Europe have their own serious problems (just look at the history of all the wars!), and especially the first one has propagandists all over as well. I am speaking against tankies here, because the propagandists are prevalent in lemmy, and since there are a lot of people already critical of the Western world, their propaganda has a good potential to have an effect. Support for Russia, for example, can affect the war in Ukraine, or help spreading the war and instability in other places in Europe (Russia supports a lot of the far-right movements), support for CCP, might help erasing the minorities, affect Taiwan-situation, help CCP control their diaspora etc.
The disinformation is, what I am against. Not Chinese or Russian people, or cultures. I do not even care, if history is debated, since there are plenty of viewpoints depending on culture, and none are necessary wrong. But when that history is used as a tool, to help war, genocide and other attrocities happen right now, that is not acceptable. No matter, who is doing it.
None of what you said is true, though.
First, you vaguely reference “atrocities,” then say tankies either minimize or deny their existence. Without knowing exactly what you mean, without actually referencing a specific event, it’s impossible to say what tankies actually believe, because the ideology of Marxism-Leninism requires us to look at every event in its proper context and understand what led to them, not just assuming magical forces of good and evil were at play.
Second, tankies do not support the Russian Federation. Tankies critically support Russia as a country undermining the US Empire. Tankies do not believe imperialism is a whim of this or that country, but instead a stage in capitalism, a stage more advanced than Russia’s economy is at. The basis of imperialism is monopoly finance capital, Russia is a largely industrial country with very little finance capital to speak of, and thus cannot run on the export of capital to plunder the global south. The global south is plundered not by Russia, but by the US and western Europe.
Third, China is not capitalist. China marketizes underdeveloped sectors of the economy, while having social ownership of the commanding heights of the economy. This is based on the Marxist understanding of contradiction and the economic basis of different forms of production. The basis of markets is in disparate, decentralized production, while the basis of planned economy is in centralized production.
Markets naturally centralize through competition and technological advancement, preparing themselves for planned economy. To plan underdeveloped sectors of the economy is to place strain on administration, because the mechanisms and infrastructure to plan such an industry has not been developed yet through markets. This is classical Marxist economics, views held by Marx, Engels, and Lenin.
Fourth, tankies do not support genocide. This returns us to the first section, you’re intentionally vague, because to name a specific genocide you believe tankies support is to invite investigation into your claims.
Fifth, tankies do want worker ownership of the means of production. That’s why they support socialist countries like China, Cuba, etc. Tankies do not support the erasure of Tibetan culture, which is not going on. What’s happening is Mandarin is being promoted within Tibet alongside traditional Tibetan language and culture, because Mandarin is often necessary to participate in the broader Chinese economy. It isn’t an erasure of Tibetan language or culture.
It sounds like you just hate communism, period, and want to blame that on tankies.
I think your account might be on the wrong instance if you’re a tankie
IMHO it’s just a good server for anyone
I’d disagree, given one of the rules is “No Tankie shit.”
TIL
Wait until China starts poaching scientists and engineers after all their citizens have left poverty.
Some scientists leaving can be ignored to maintain the illusion of freedom but if the majority wants to leave, obstacles will be created.
China has a fine history of subjecting scientists, doctors and other thinkers to forced labour on collective farms instead of doing what they are good at.
People of color, women, communists - the West has its own history. If life or research is better in China, people will leave.
That is a big if there. Censorship usually weakens academia, which leads to slower scientific progress
We had censorship about electric vehicles. I don’t think China is at a disadvantage.
Why the disagreement? We could have gone electric much earlier.
I’m genuinely wondering if the only way to answer the comment you answered to is whataboutism.
Two wrongs don’t make a right.
I don’t know the history that well. In Cuba, everybody had to work on a farm for community building. If they did that it would be even good. I think Xi Jinping also worked on a farm. If even the elite does it then it’s their culture and should be a good thing.
Besides that, it’s not the whataboutism fallacy to show that the other side has the same moral flaw. Whataboutism is to change the topic to an unrelated flaw, e.g. the environmental destruction.
That was back when most humans were farmers. If we were to do it today, it should be working at a retail store and/or food service.
The place of an engineer is automating production, including agriculture.
(I’ve worked all four of these)
There are tons of promising young engineers who come from China to the US to get an education. Once they are done, many beg the US government to let them stay while the US immigration system looks for any reason to send them back. If you ask me, if someone gets a PHD in a highly demanded field, they should be automatically eligible to apply for permanent resident status.
Source: I have worked with plenty of people stuck in the student visa to work visa purgatory. I assume it is the same across all STEM fields.
There are tons of promising young engineers who come from China to the US to get an education.
For now. People will stop coming if conditions are better in China, and those who came, will leave. Not only Chinese, but with ICE in town, why should any scientist stay in the US once laboratories are better in China?
They already shouldn’t stay! There are much better places to live than both the USA and China.
Lmao, maybe in the 90s.
My experience is from the 2010’s. I am not sure how it has been post pandemic, I switched companies and my new team is not hiring much.
I am not saying that every bright Chinese student wants to come to the US to get their education and then stay for a job. I am saying that the US should be doing more to retain those that do.
The US should be sanctioned out of existence and balkanized.
It was still true until roughly ten years ago. In fact, I distinctly remember several media outlets (both left and right) noting that wealthy Chinese tourists were becoming a global issue by acting almost like now-modern Israelis while abroad - without the genocidal attitudes and active hatred for anyone not them, that is. Just generally being entitled and disrespectful to whichever local culture they were visiting. Hm. So maybe just generally acting American, I guess. This was also around the time that meme was going around where the rich Chinese kids were taking pictures of themselves falling out of their cars with all the most expensive things they own scattered on the ground like it all fell out of their pockets. You know, to show off their bougie shit for social media clout.
Once they are done, many beg the US government to let them stay
This is the part I was laughing at.
Fair play
It’s almost as if it was just fascism with red trim.
Socialism, economies where public ownership is the principal aspect and the working class controls the state, is a polar opposite to fascism, which is capitalism stripped of bourgeois democracy and replaced with naked rule by capital directly. Who the state is run by, and who society works to improve, is entirely different. In socialism, the working class is the primary beneficiary of social production, while in fascism it’s the capitalist class.
Horseshoe detected
You’re not in your silly little echo chamber so your silly little thought terminating cliche doesn’t work here.
Pointing out that Horseshoe Theory is absurd isn’t a thought terminating cliché, that would be calling communism “red fascism.” Further, it seems calling out Horseshoe Theory is in fact working, and your views are just unpopular in general.
Explain how socialism is fascism please, lol
That’s not what horseshoe theory is about.
Proponents point to a number of real and perceived similarities between the two extremes, such as tendencies to see politics in unambiguous and stereotypical terms; an “us vs. them” view of the world; holding confidently on to simplified views of the world; distrusting “authorities” and “elites”; and intense hostility towards those who hold other views.
Lol.
From your same link:
The horseshoe theory is not widely supported within academic circles; peer-reviewed research by political scientists on the subject is scarce, and existing studies and comprehensive reviews have often contradicted its central premises, or found only limited support for the theory under certain conditions.[31][32][weasel words] A 2011 study about the far-left and the far-right within the context of the 2007 French presidential election concluded: “Divergent social and political logics explain the electoral support for these two candidates: their voters do not occupy the same political space, they do not have the same social background, and they do not hold the same values.”[1] A 2012 study concluded: “The present results thus do not corroborate the idea that adherents to extreme ideologies on the left-wing and right-wing sides resemble each other but instead support the alternative perspective that different extreme ideologies attract different people. In other words, extremists should be distinguished on the basis of the ideology to which they adhere, and there is no universal extremist type that feels at home in any extreme ideology.”[31] A 2019 study concluded that “our findings suggest that speaking of ‘extreme left-wing values’ or ‘extreme right-wing values’ may not be meaningful, as members of both groups are heterogeneous in the values that they endorse.”[33] A 2022 study about antisemitism concluded: “On all items, the far left has lower agreement with these statements relative to moderates, and the far right has higher agreement with these statements compared to moderates. Contrary to a ‘horseshoe’ theory, the evidence reveals increasing antisemitism moving from left to right.”[32] Paul H. P. Hanel, a research associate at the University of Essex, et al. summarised some of those studies. They wrote:
Likewise, some even argue that all extremists, across the political left and right, in fact, support similar policies, in a view known as ‘horseshoe theory’. However, not only do recent studies fail to support such beliefs, they also contradict them … Van Hiel also found that left-wing respondents reported significantly lower endorsement of values associated with conservation, self-enhancement, and anti-immigration attitudes compared to both moderate and right-wing activists, with individuals on the right reporting greater endorsement of such values and attitudes … Overall, van Hiel provided evidence demonstrating that Western European extremist groups are far from being homogenous, and left- and right-wing groups represent distinct ideologies.[33]
Several scholars dismissed the theory as an oversimplification and generalisation that ignores their fundamental differences,[34][35] and have questioned the theory’s general premises, citing significative differences of the left and right on the political spectrum and governance.[36][37] Chip Berlet, an expert on right-wing movements, has dismissed perceived far-left–far-right flirtations as an oversimplification of political ideologies, ignoring fundamental differences between them. In a 2000 book about the radical right in the United States, Right-Wing Populism in America: Too Close for Comfort, he and Matthew N. Lyons, another expert on right-wing movements, dismissed both the claim that the far-right’s role in the 1999 Seattle protests was significant, and a Southern Poverty Law Center report that “relied heavily on centrist/extremist analysis”. Within the context of the anti-globalisation movement, they also mentioned that those on the political left were concerned about the far-right infiltrating anti-World Trade Organization groups, including those led by centrist liberals and social democrats that did not want to be associated with “right-wing nationalists and bigots”. Some, such as the Peoples’ Global Action, responded to this perceived threat by amending their manifestos to specifically reject alliances with any right-wing groups, on principle.[34]
In a 2014 paper, Vassilis Pavlopoulos, a professor in social psychology at the University of Athens, argued: “The so-called centrist/extremist or horseshoe theory points to notorious similarities between the two extremes of the political spectrum (e.g., authoritarianism). It remains alive though many sociologists consider it to have been thoroughly discredited (Berlet & Lyons, 2000). Furthermore, the ideological profiles of the two political poles have been found to differ considerably (Pavlopoulos, 2013). The centrist/extremist hypothesis narrows civic political debate and undermines progressive organising. Matching the neo-Nazi with the radical left leads to the legitimisation of far-right ideology and practices.”[37]
Simon Choat, a senior lecturer in political theory at Kingston University, has criticised the horseshoe theory. In a 2017 article for The Conversation, “‘Horseshoe theory’ is nonsense – the far right and far left have little in common”, he argues that far-left and far-right ideologies only share similarities in the vaguest sense, in that they both oppose the liberal democratic status quo, but that the two sides have very different reasons and very different aims for doing so.[38] Choat uses the issue of globalisation as an example;[39] both the far-left and the far-right attack neoliberal globalisation and its “elites”, but identify different elites and have conflicting reasons for attacking them.[40] Additionally, Choat argues that although proponents of the horseshoe theory may cite historical examples of alleged collusion between fascists and communists,[41] those on the far-left usually oppose the rise of far-right or fascist regimes in their countries. Instead, he argues that it has been centrists who have supported far-right and fascist regimes and have preferred them in power over socialists,[42] and that the horseshoe theory is biased towards centrists, who he says use it to smear or attack the left more than the right.[43] He cites the example of the 2016 United States presidential election and the 2017 French presidential election, in which supporters of Bernie Sanders and Jean-Luc Mélenchon were alleged to have preferred or voted for Donald Trump and Marine Le Pen.[44] In this sense, he argues that the horseshoe theory is used to engage in red-baiting or reductio ad Hitlerum, which allows them to “discredit the left while disavowing their own complicity with the far right.”[35] Choat says that “it is patently absurd to compare Stalin to present-day leftists like Mélenchon or Corbyn”,[35] and concludes: “If liberals genuinely want to understand and confront the rise of the far right, then rather than smearing the left they should perhaps reflect on their own faults.”[35]
While formal academic or journalistic analysis of horseshoe theory is fairly recent, criticism of its antecedents is long-standing, and a frequent basis for criticism has been the tendency of commentators to group disparate opposing movements together. As early as 1938, Marxist theorist and politician Leon Trotsky wrote “Their Morals and Ours”, which became the basis for his 1939 book, Their Morals and Ours: Marxist Versus Liberal Views on Morality. In the 1938 article, which was first published in the United States by the theoretical journal of the Socialist Workers Party of the International Left Opposition, he wrote:
The fundamental feature of [arguments comparing disparate political movements] lies in their completely ignoring the material foundation of the various currents, that is, their class nature and by that token their objective historical role. Instead they evaluate and classify different currents according to some external and secondary manifestation … To Hitler, liberalism and Marxism are twins because they ignore ‘blood and honour’. To a democrat, fascism and Bolshevism are twins because they do not bow before universal suffrage … Different classes in the name of different aims may in certain instances utilise similar means. Essentially it cannot be otherwise. Armies in combat are always more or less symmetrical; were there nothing in common in their methods of struggle they could not inflict blows upon each other.[45][46]
No academic takes Horseshoe Theory seriously, and in fact its a thought terminating cliché.
Yeah, that was my point. I wasn’t the one that brought it up.
Lmfao, you don’t even know what the subject of the discussion was!? Wild to see such misplaced confidence.
The person implying socialism and fascism are merely aesthetically different was directly referencing Horseshoe Theory. It follows from Arendt’s theory of “Totalitarianism” as a unifying thread between the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany, which was only historically relevant as a way for the US to pit itself against both the Nazis and the Communists, despite having far more in common with Nazi Germany and the Communists being polar opposites to both.
You’re not in your silly little echo chamber so your silly little thought terminating cliche doesn’t work here.
Lol
Socialism is democratic control of the factors of production, not just when things are nationalized.
It’s a bit more than that, socialism is a transitional mode of production and distribution where the working class controls the state, and social ownership is the principal aspect of the economy (ie, rising and dominant). Workplace democracy within capitalism isn’t socialism, and while democracy is core to how socialism necessarily functions, not every decision needs to be made electorally.
Oh I know what it means lmao
You don’t think that has anything to do with the literal Nazis marching into their country to exterminate them?
the berlin wall was created long after the fall of nazy germany. It was build to prevent people to flee to the west
You don’t think it had anything to do with keeping the literal Nazis who were put in charge by the Americans in West germany out?
If it did, the defences would be built the other way around.
The anti climbing wall could easily be scaled from the west by ladder undetected, the vehicle ditch is oriented to stop someone leaving, the alarm is on the east side, …
Same goes for the inner German border, who would put a ditch behind the fence and minefield? Noone!you mean: building a multi million DeutshMark wall, because, west germany, a demilarized country, with no army, a nuremberg trial killing the nazi , and the remaining of them findind a paradise in argentina, that country would somehow have former nazi still willing and being able to invade east germany?
Perspective from Germany: Denazification didn’t work great, they mostly just punished the big names. A lot of nazi government and military officials just got reinstated.
That said, fleeing the DDR was very illegal, and a lot of east German people died trying to cross that border. At the same time, the BRD just keeping old nazi laws on the books meant that women’s and (some) queer rights where decades ahead in the DDR. I’m not saying that the DDR, as a whole, was good, but the picture isn’t wholly black and white.
Do me a favor and read up about the failure of denazification and Operation Paperclip.
You think the USSR didn’t have their own Operation Paperclip? You mean you haven’t read up on Operation Osoaviakhim?
Do you think those two things are equivalent? Have you read up on either?
The major difference is that the US protected and elevated Nazis to the highest positions, including in NATO (such as Adolf Heusinger), while the Soviets kept the Nazi scientists under tight control, underprivledged conditions, and essentially sent them back to Germany once they were done. Calling Operation Osoaviakhim a “Soviet Operation Paperclip” entirely minimizes the enormous elevation of Nazis in countries around the globe, like Argentina, where they became steadfast allies for the rising US Empire.
you really are moving the goal post. How paperclip an american operation to recruit nazy to america has anything to do with building a wall to “protect” east germany from invading nazi (your unhinge theory) ? dont bother replying , I wont untertain this conversation anymore.
Because the Americans were in charge of West Germany, failed at denazification, which is a known historical fact, and instead installed Nazis into positions of power in West Germany.
None of this is controversial, lol.
Keeping them out of the country where literal Nazis were put in charge by the Soviets in East Germany? No, I don’t believe that for one second.
Up to 25% of the SED’s initial members were former NSDAP members, according to this well-sourced article.
Lmfao. The Russians executed the Nazis they found. The Americans gave them a plot of land and a job at NATO or NASA.
The major difference is that the US protected and elevated Nazis to the highest positions, including in NATO (such as Adolf Heusinger), while the Soviets kept the Nazi scientists under tight control, underprivledged conditions, and essentially sent them back to Germany once they were done. Calling Operation Osoaviakhim a “Soviet Operation Paperclip” entirely minimizes the enormous elevation of Nazis in countries around the globe, like Argentina, where they became steadfast allies for the rising US Empire.
Lmfao
Wikipedia
Lmfao.
You can follow the reference links.














