- cross-posted to:
- keralalinux@lemmy.ca
- cross-posted to:
- keralalinux@lemmy.ca
Sloppity slop.
Curation will be more important than ever now for media of all kinds. That and local small groups. Maybe this is a good thing. Find the trust in one another again.
I wonder if this will open up a new curator market. Kinda like reviewers but not dependent on publishers to send them games for free, but supported by their followers to buy games, try them, and say which ones they think are good and which suck (and why). Tastes will factor in, so it will be important to find a curator or set of curators whose tastes line up well with yours.
Saying this because I’m assuming the next step (or current) is gaming the hell out of user reviews, though it might be difficult for them to scale that if valve puts any effort into cracking down on that.
It’s not curator but a better discovery engine: steampeek.hu.
I’m glad steam already has this functionality implemented… Just have to find some trusted curators.
I honestly can’t even bring myself to be excited for new projects anymore, even from devs that I previously liked.
The slopification has gotten bad, and this wave of slop generators that get so fucking offended when called out for it is so tiresome.
I miss the days of shitty rpgmaker games, at least the devs of those actually had passion, these slopgens don’t even have that.
Honestly my backlog is so big anymore, it doesn’t even really matter. Nothing new has really impressed me all that much anyways. I’m about to boot the ps5 up and blow my brains out on GTA VI for the next few months, this is bad timing for steam because I usually buy a few games at Black Friday, but doubt I’ll even look this year because I just literally don’t want anything anyways.
My backlog starts from games made in 1990 so I have a damn long way to go just hope my consoles keep working when I’m retired.
Huge backlog and you are supporting GTA VI? Shame.
Same regarding my backlog. With 500+ games across platforms that I haven’t even installed yet, I am not looking for more games.
All I ever play is Rocket League anyway.
Honestly, I do think Valve need to start curating games again, because there is just so much low-effort cash-grab slopware nowadays.
Like I’m aware that it’ll make games take longer to release - but it’d be for the better long-term.
Letting adult games on the platform was a huge mistake. That led to about 20,000 porn games being released in a couple years. The “let games float or sink on their merit” does not work on Steam anymore.
Letting adult games onto Steam was bad because then adult games were on Steam.
That is what you just said.
This is a tautology, devoid of meaning and logic.
If you don’t like adult games on Steam, you can filter Steam so you don’t see them.
Are you trying to say something perhaps more interesting, or do you just not like that adult games exist and some people like to play them?
Or do you just not like the ‘visual novel’ format?
… Again?
Are you saying they should go back to Steam Greenlight, back before then?
That Steam/Valve should manually human review an entire publishing/listing agreement for every applicant?
If you wanna destroy the video gaming indie scene, that’d be how you’d do that. You’d be cutting away 95%-99% of games published per year.
Valve only has like 300 employees doing everything that Valve does. They build layers and layers of processes and automated testing and sorting and flagging and categorizing so that they don’t have to subcontract out 4,000 people in basically a call center somewhere, its the same reason the steam ‘forums’ are notoriously a wretched hive of scum and villainy.
A human only ever gets involved when something has seriously tripped a bunch of red flags in a fairly uncommon, or new and novel way.
Also that exists.
It would probably be a good excercise for just anybody to scroll through that site, see how there are different kinds of AI use, some are arguably more justifiable than others (indie game translating text for localization vs AAA game generating entire seasonal update of micropurchasable cosmetics, etc), and that you almost certainly own at least one game that does have some amount of AI in it or involved in making it, if you bought literally any game in the last 3 years.
Or, you could maybe use GoG, who … actually do the old handpicked curation thing, and do it pretty damned well, imo.
The irony of https://gameaicheck.com/ being developed by AI and using AI to determine of a game is AI 😅
Theoretically it takes one to know one, I suppose, hahaha!
While I do think that it would be better for curation to be 3rd party and not done by valve choosing which games live or die, I also think that if you have a service that you’re scaling up, you should hire the support staff such a service would require. Valve can certainly afford to hire more than 300 people.
But that defeats the entire way that Steam is designed. It is meant to accept all comers, who meet guidelines, and be the video gaming everything store. Thats… the entire strategy.
Valve doesn’t choose what games live or die. The… the players do. The whole way Steam works is by crowdsourcing reviews and descriptions and such, thats what powers its ‘algorithm’. Now sure, this system isn’t perfect… but its like the core idea of Steam, that its a kind of psuedo democracy… the player base are the curators, not some editorial board of 10ish people.
There are tons of different ways to search for games by different kinds of filters and such… I’ll give you that some of them aren’t super useful for everyone, but you can dial down to a pretty niche set of traits you want in a game, if you wanna be particular.
Steam has curators. It has a whole system for curators, for becoming one, for following one… there’s nothing stopping you from becoming a curator, if you can’t find any you think are good.
Steam can afford to subcontract out to a call center, yes. But they want to keep their operation small and local, in line with their flat hierarchy/voluntary clique form of getting things done, that is rather unique as a business culture / ‘management’ style.
Throw on a bunch of subcontractors, it breaks that, its diamtetrically opposed to it.
And also… they don’t need to hire more people, if they continue to have a small number of the most competent people in the industry, continue being very clever in designing systems that automate the mind numbing busy work you’d otherwise have contractors doing.
You’re asking Steam to stop being Steam. GoG exists if you want a well curated game market place thats like what you say you want.
Not entirely sure if they’re already doing this or not, but the following seems like a broadly good idea to me:
You upload a game to Steam that fits into its ‘uses AI’ categories?
Second tier processing log, 2 to 4 weeks untill expected full pre-review and actual publishing.
All natural human generated game?
Primary tier processing log, aim for 3 to 7 days untill full pre-review and actual publishing.
… game you claimed was all natural, gets published, steam then crowdsource categorizes it as full of AI?
Pull it off the market, throw it into the second tier processing log, auto offer refunds to anyone who bought it initially.
So yeah, slop goes into the slop pipeline, non slop goes into the normal pipeline.
Is that perfect? Nope!
But it doesn’t need to be perfect, it needs to work better than the existing paradigm.
Also, maybe add some more text somewhere that makes it clear to people that they should expect these kinds of time delays, and that they probably shouldn’t promise release dates to their fans that hinge on everything going perfectly.
I’m 99% sure this already exists, but people are idiots, including game devs, maybe have a page with a yellow trail leading to a big yellow box that says this again.
You can always, you know, upload a first release build a month before your marketed/advertised release date, instead of 24hrs before.
IMO, if your ‘business model’ as a game developer cannot handle that, you basically deserve to fail.
They don’t care. They didn’t care when the store was flooded with basic asset flips, and they don’t care now that ai makes it even easier. They intend to collect $100 from every crappy game and let community reviews and collections handle curation.
It’s delaying real games at this point, which effects their income.
The number of releases isn’t really the problem, discovery is. The store front and discovery queue keep pushing the same top sellers, so good small games just sink. Most of what I buy now comes from a couple of curators I trust and from what friends are playing.
I’ve had cases where I go through my discovery queue often enough that it said there wasn’t anything more to show. Only to later discover some more games that were out at that time but it just never showed me for some reason.
And I’m skeptical about it just using my tastes and thinking I wouldn’t like it because it shows me shit like FIFA that I haven’t shown any interest in anything like that before.
I dunno, I’ve found the new calendar page to be pretty helpful for finding new, often obscure, games (especially if you click the max number of games per page option)
The comments on the article paint a picture…
I would say easily 90% of the games sent directly to our Steam Curator are either pure slop, or very clearly a “my first game” sort of basic thing. Very noisy, takes forever to sift through.
Soon, people will just have a checkbox to filter out any majority-AI games, and then it will be back to business as usual, with all the slop quarantined.
Until then, we must brave the torrent of crap.
Right because slop vendors really love to accurately represent their product. Can’t possibly be this naive.
Is this a brag or a complaint?
Given that this is yet another AI-related thing, complaint. I don’t like having to seep through hundreds of slop copycats to find the good stuff. Kind of what killed gaming for me on Android even before AI.
It’s what killed gaming in the Atari era and caused the video game crash of ‘83
Nintendo was able to save the industry by introducing the “nintendo seal of approval”, so consumers didn’t have to wade through slop. They knew if they saw that seal, it was a curated pick and likely to be quality.
Steam actually already has a curation system, just have to know who to follow (I recommend Commander Shepard)
I get that the Commander Shepard is for memes, but … eh, low effort crawler bot that just keeps pasting the same thing over and over? It even said some accounting application is his favorite game.
It’s a human who posts intermittently, they’ve been less actively lately sadly, the page has been running for a while
Every game reviewed is his favorite lol. It’s a joke from Mass Effect, where you can take sponsorships from different shops on the main space station, and record a short video for them (always the same line, “I’m commander shepard and this is my favorite shop on the citadel”)
So as you continue doing it, eventually every shop you walk by plays the same ad. The steam page is set up to recreate that joke
I like hella yuri (curator)
(curator)
Good save.
I’ve stopped looking and buying. I have a few things that are older than llm usage on the wishlist for sales. Other than that, I’m not touching anything not recommended by people I know and on sale.














